Halex's avatar

Halex

  • USA
  • Joined Aug 18, 2013
  • ? / M
sort

Biggest Dissapointments: Overrated Animes

This is a list of animes that I find dissapointing. They are not necessarily the worst shows but at the very least I was expecting more from them and consider them overrated. Most of the time they have great animation but fail at storytelling, wich in my personal opinion is more important than the visuals. These shows rank pretty high despite their shortcomings.
1 Rainbow: Nisha Rokubou no Shichinin

Rainbow: Nisha Rokubou no Shichinin

This is by far my biggest disappointment in anime!

This story is supposed to be about resistance against oppressive regimes, fighting for freedom, maintaining your ideals despite the circumstances, and redeeming your life. It's supposed to be a serious story seinen style. These are some of my favorite themes in a compelling story. By the time I tried to watch this abomination, it only had reviews of 9+ ranking (still most reviews are like that), so my expectations were quite high that I was going to like this one. I kept watching with the belief that it was going to get better but the opposite was true. Give back those 10 hours of my life dammit!

The Problem?

The execution of the story is extremely contrived, to the point the characters' personalities change completely as needed for the plot to advance in a certain way and 'make you feel' certain emotions.

The author should have done more research in the psychology of people in situations like the ones presented in this story. I have met people in lighter but similar circumstances and this is not the way people react, nor thinks. Yet, there are plenty of reviews calling this anime 'realistic'.

The only anime that I can think of with similar themes & setting is perhaps Attack on Titan, which is in a league of its own. There are no other animes similar to Rainbow that I can recommend, but there are plenty of films for better stories with similar themes:

2 your name.

your name.

Best anime movie of all time? No way, not in a million years!

That title belongs in my opinion to Ghost in the Shell. This film was so ahead of its time that even today fits perfectly at current anime standards. The intricate plot, the futuristic designs, and the philosophy and ideas presented in this work have created a timeless masterpiece that has influenced movies like The MatrixAvatar & Surrogates to name a few. Not to mention its latest live-action adaptation with Scarlett Johansson. There is no question that this film has greatly influenced the sci-fi genre and helped bring anime into the attention of everyone. Ghost in the Shell - Watching Guide

The Problem?

It's just another movie with excellent graphics and smooth animation but terrible storytelling that is contrived, full of plot holes & inconsistencies. Having the protagonists forget everything they experienced completely renders their learning experience useless, so the movie ignores this when its convenient for the plot in order to continue the story, and you are just supposed to go along and numb your brain to all this?

I'll have to argue than while watching Ghost in the Shell makes you smarter, your name ask you for the opposite in order to be enjoyable :(

The title of best of all time usually depends on each person's preferred genre and what they feel is most important, but even for Adventure/Slice-of-Life/Romance there are better titles out there than 'your name.'

Any of the movies I recommend far surpasses 'your name.' in my opinion.

3 Great Pretender

Great Pretender

This anime started great and it was on its way to awesomeness until the last case, at which point it just comes tumbling down to hell and left me wondering if someone was up to sabotage the story and I can't understand why they decided to throw everything away and stomp on their own work as a piece of trash.

The series' story is divided into small arcs called "Cases":

  • Case 1Los Angeles Connection is Episodes 1-5
  • Case 2Singapore Sky is Episodes 6-10
  • Case 3Snow of London is Episodes 11-14
    • Up to here, everything is almost perfect. I strongly recommend you stop here for the best experience.
    • If you decide to continue with the last case all remaining questions & backstory of the main protagonist will be answered, but it's so bad that it will destroy everything you see so far and you cannot undo that. It's like they stop caring about the story and just wanted to finish the anime without care or consideration for the character development, the cohesion of the story, and the message they were trying to convey. It will leave you feeling that the show was a waste of time.
    • I would rate the story up to this point an 8.
  • Case 4Wizard of Far East is Episodes 15-23
    • I have to wonder: if this last case is Filler Material? If it is, that will explain a lot, as it feels like it was giving to a different writer, and not just any writer, but someone either set on sabotage all the work they have done so far or an amateur writer with no experience nor care about the work.
    • It is even worst than the last Filler Arc of Gantz, and even worst than the ending of Game of Thrones, which seems to have the same kind of issues as this last case.
    • This is one of the most disappointing endings that I have ever seen in anime and any other format.

The first 3 cases are definitely worth watching, the story is not overly serious, it has a good amount of comedy and wackiness. As far as I remember this is the first anime about Con Artist, there other animes about gambling that also include some conning, but it's not the main focus of those shows.

The animation & sound are awesome, as expected from Wit Studio.

Overall, It's an interesting show with a different premise & style from the norm. It may not be for everyone but you should at least try the first 2 episodes before you decide.

The dub was good.

4 Arakawa Under the Bridge

Arakawa Under the Bridge

5 Neon Genesis Evangelion

Neon Genesis Evangelion

6 Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion

Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion

7 Perfect Blue

Perfect Blue

Don't get me wrong, I think this movie is great! It has excellent animation especially for its time of release in 1998, with a very realistic style. The plot is well developed and it conveys the feelings of thriller & fear quite well.

So What's The Problem?

Although this style is new in anime form, it has been done a lot in Hollywood movies and is perhaps not what anime does best. This story could have just as easily been created as a real-life film, in fact, I think it shares many commonalities with films like The Silence of the Lambs (1991), Psycho (1960), and perhaps thrillers like Se7en (1995).

I think anime has the advantage to go beyond imitating real-life and it should be used as such to bring our imagination to life, to tell stories beyond what could be told in a real-life film. So this is just my personal opinion, although I recognize Perfect Blue is a film that left its mark in the anime industry, and its a great film!

8 Drifting Dragons

Drifting Dragons

So I was very excited about this anime, it looked great with good animation in a fantasy setting until I discovered that this was essentially propaganda for whale hunting. It tries to romanticize and even elicit the desire for dragon/whale hunting for no other reason than 'they taste great and I want to eat them'. :(

You can read my full review here.

9 Girls und Panzer

Girls und Panzer

This was actually recommended to me as a Strategies & Tactics Anime and they were quite serious about that. Being myself a fan of such genres I couldn't wait to see these girls in tanks, but it turned out to be a moe series from the unofficial genre of Cute Girls Doing Cute Things like driving tanks? :(

Nothing wrong with moe, it's just not my preferred genre and I was expecting an intelligent strategies & tactics anime after all.

If you like moe & comedy then you'll probably like this anime. Try a few episodes to see if you enjoy it, the rest of the anime will be the same.

If you are like me and are looking for actual Strategies & Tactics then I rather recommend: 

10 Planetes

Planetes

11 Lu Over the Wall

Lu Over the Wall

12 5 Centimeters per Second

5 Centimeters per Second

13 The Girl Who Leapt Through Time

The Girl Who Leapt Through Time

14 In This Corner of the World

In This Corner of the World

15 Guilty Crown

Guilty Crown

16 Mind Game

Mind Game

17 FLIP FLAPPERS

FLIP FLAPPERS

18 Get Backers

Get Backers

19 Assassination Classroom

Assassination Classroom

20 Attack on Titan: Lost Girls

Attack on Titan: Lost Girls

21 Natsume's Book of Friends

Natsume's Book of Friends

22 Yuri!!! on Ice

Yuri!!! on Ice

23 No Game No Life

No Game No Life

24 Gun x Sword

Gun x Sword

25 Banana Fish

Banana Fish

26 Wolf's Rain

Wolf's Rain

27 Mermaid Forest TV

Mermaid Forest TV

28 Pokemon

Pokemon

After committing to 276 episodes I learned that Ash was doomed to forever be a loser and teach kids that their dreams will never come through as long as the corporate overlords are making a profit out of you!

Why does Ash never win a Pokémon League championship?

I never watched another Pokemon show afterward and never intend to do so. I'm probably not the only one who thinks like this so that probably forced the corporate overlords to let Ash finally wins after 22 years! Not that I'm interested anymore in watching that.

I always was interested in seeing the progression of his story as he grows up but that didn't happen either.

29 Flag

Flag

30 Fate/Grand Order: Absolute Demonic Front - Babylonia

Fate/Grand Order: Absolute Demonic Front - Babylonia

If you are expecting the great characterization and a seriously driven plot like in "Stay Night/Zero" installments, then you'll be greatly disappointed!

This has great animation, especially with the use of camera movements, but nothing that sets it apart from other animes in 2019. The fights have amazing motion & eye candy, but the fighting moves often make no sense, and they are resolved using Deus ex machina. Why they are fighting anyway? The reasons make no sense either, characters just meet each other and start fighting. The excuse is often just a stubborn personality and silly misunderstandings. It has a lot of fanservice as well.

This may be entertaining but nothing more, it has a plotline & characterization made for kids, but it's too bloody to let them watch this and too silly for teens & young adults, so I'm not sure Who is the intended audience? They added a lot of comic relief and as in any comedy, some people laugh, some don't; I didn't so I can't recommend it for that either. You can try a few episodes for yourself, but in the end, I think it is just average and offers nothing new to the genre or the franchise. There are better animes where you can spend your time!

Fate/Series - Watching Guide

31 Fate/Apocrypha

Fate/Apocrypha

It's average at best.

The story is set in a parallel world (to the main Fate/Stay Night universe) in which the Grail was removed from Fuyuki City after the Third War, so the events of Fate/ZeroFate/Stay Night 2006 & Unlimited Blade Works never occurred. The story focuses on the clash between the two opposing factions, Red vs. Black, with each summoning 7 Servants of their own, and the Grail itself summoning a special "Ruler Class" servant as a mediator of this Holy Grail War. Whether or not it can be considered canon has not yet been determined, but I'm inclined to say "no" as it's definitely "filler quality"! Just consider the servants: Dracula, Frankenstein, Jack The Ripper, Shakespeare? Common! LoL. Furthermore, the overuse of changing gender for famous male servants is ridiculous, taking away from the seriousness of the show.

The best part of the series is the music! Read the reviews if you are still curious.

Fate/Series - Watching Guide

32 The Heroic Legend of Arslan

The Heroic Legend of Arslan

33 Lord El-Melloi II's Case Files {Rail Zeppelin} Grace note

Lord El-Melloi II's Case Files {Rail Zeppelin} Grace note

If you watched Fate/Zero, then you'll probably remember Waver Velvet the Master of Rider (Alexander the Great, Iskander, King of Conquerors) and after being inspired by Rider you may have wondered how that meeting was going to change his life for the better and his personality, which we see improving a great deal during the war.

So this is a spinoff focusing on this character. After the events of Fate/Zero, he returned to the Clock Tower to resume his study of magecraft where due to the decline of the El-Melloi clan, Waver assumes the title of Lord El-Melloi II after agreeing to assist the true heir, Reines El-Melloi Archisorte, in restoring the clan until she is old enough to take charge. The story takes place 10 years after the events of Fate/Zero and 2 months before the events of Fate/Stay Night

I found the new personality of Waver Velvet quite disappointing and out of character for what we saw in Fate/Zero. I think this installment has a lot of missed opportunities to further develop this character and apply what he learned from Rider.

Fate/Series - Watching Guide

34 The Diary of Tortov Roddle

The Diary of Tortov Roddle

Very interesting and artistic animation, but uninteresting and boring stories.

35 Bungo Stray Dogs

Bungo Stray Dogs

36 ACCA: 13-Territory Inspection Dept.

ACCA: 13-Territory Inspection Dept.

37 Towanoquon Movie 1: The Ephemeral Petals

Towanoquon Movie 1: The Ephemeral Petals

38 The Flowers of Evil

The Flowers of Evil

39 Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai

Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai

40 Hyouka

Hyouka

41 Hinamatsuri

Hinamatsuri

42 Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle

Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle

43 Lovely Complex

Lovely Complex

44 Terror in Resonance

Terror in Resonance

45 Shakugan no Shana

Shakugan no Shana

46 Flavors of Youth

Flavors of Youth

47 Kokoro Connect

Kokoro Connect

48 X TV

X TV

49 The Night is Short, Walk On Girl

The Night is Short, Walk On Girl

50 Mary and the Witch's Flower

Mary and the Witch's Flower

Comments

You must be logged in to leave comments. or

There are no comments - leave one to be the first!