Himitsu: The Revelation - Reviews

sort
lokieternal's avatar
Oct 22, 2013

Story:

There is a serious problem. It’s called tedious mediocrity.  This isn’t even a good who done it.  When reading the description, I thought oh, this is going to be interesting! Maybe I expected more surrealism, more mystery, or…something. My first question was: If we can use this magical MRI to ‘see’ a person’s memory, why can’t we hear anything? That distracted me for the entire duration of the show.

My other issues was that each episode a full case. The most you get is the occasional 2 ep story arc. For a good mystery, in order to get involved and have enough complexity, the story arcs needed to be a little longer.

At first you think it’s going to be murder of the week. It actually stays that way except for the rare two parters. There is an undercurrent story line that is threaded through the entire series, too bad it doesn’t draw you in. I actually did finish it, and I’m surprised.

Another problem is that it would throw out these ‘risqué’ themes as if their concepts made for good plot twists. I suppose if you are green and naive, that might just work.  There were things in there that it would tell you outright, for example Aoiki is in love with his sister and then it just drops it. This is a pretty big issue for someone to have. I understand his work is really demanding, but how can you be in love with someone for that long and just not think about it, ever, is just kinda of unrealistic. It’s not that I wanted to watch him pine over it or anything, it’s just that there should have been something there, like a thorn in your side, or a needle under your nail, a boil on your butt – it just doesn’t poof go away because you want it to, and something like that, you can’t just ignore it. Who knows, maybe he got off screen therepy.  He went to her wedding and was happy and fine. But then again, by that time he’d been working with Maki for a while.

About that. I make no secret that I read a bunch of yaoi. I know a set up when I see it. When Aoki first meets Maki, I expected to see flower petals drop from the heavens or fireworks or sparkles – that is how yaoi like it came across. It ended like that too – but not before exploring the incredibly DISTURBING aspect of ‘oh you are a lot like my dead ex… let’s hook up in a few more months after I finish getting over it.”  Only the scene with the babies gave me deeper chills than that.  Talk about psychologically unhealthy and creepy… but then again aoki starts off crushing on his sister, why did I expect more?

I think what I’m trying to say is that there wasn’t enough substance or time. If each story arc had been longer than one episode, this anime could have been great, and interesting, there could have even been a bit of suspense. Suspense was sadly lacking – they watched stuff for a min or two and within the next few minutes figured it out – the audience barely gets a chance to get psychologically or emotionally involved with any of the cases – all of which would have been really interesting if they had been developed and played out. I feel like we got the short end of the buss.

Animation:

It was really good. There were some varying styles but everything was done well.

Sound: the background music was just completely awful. It reminded me of the old movies my grandmother and I watched, but that was not the awful part. The awful part was that the music belonged to a different setting/scene. It just didn’t match, and then it got obstructive and obtrusive. It became distracting, it was so out of place….

Some of those voice actors really needed to kill all the unnecessary noises they kept making.

Characters:

 I really didn’t like Aoki half the time; he was a whiney pants in the beginning. Then for most of the rest of the show he was too busy over reacting and making unnecessary noises. He redeemed himself in the last episode. Maki was usually likeable until he had his issues – and oh boy, when he had an issue, he got all messy and stupid. Both he and Aoki need to have some mood stabilizers. I expect professionals of their field to have a better grip on their emotions, or maybe I just watch too much Japanese dramas and am used to more calm and stable types. (Just in case you do not watch jdrama – this was sarcasm)  The rest of the cast was likeable enough that I can’t even think of anything bad about them, I can’t think of anything that stands out though.

Overall 

It was actually boring. I knew there was a ‘bigger story’ lurking in there, which is why I kept watching – but I was still rather disappointed. The stories were interesting; the plot was interesting, the execution failed.

5/10 story
8/10 animation
1/10 sound
7/10 characters
3/10 overall
duchessliz's avatar
Oct 30, 2013

Story:

What if you could look into the memories of a murder victim and see their last days? What if you could look into the memories of a serial killer to better understand them? Both prospects are suitably terrifying, but in this anime they made that a reality. With the creation of Memory Reproduction Imaging, or M.R.I, the police are given this exact ability and thus the infamous Section Nine is created. Section Nine is a very small police force made up of investigators who use the MRI to look at the memories of murder victims and / or serial killers to try to find either the killer or the motive to better understand why the murders took place. Most of the cases only take one episode to solve, but the truly compelling ones take two or three episodes to solve. Amongst all of this there is an interwining plot involving Maki, the Director of Section Nine, and what happened 18 months before during an investigation of a serial killer that led to Maki killing his best friend Suzuki. When Aoki, who reminds Maki very much of Suzuki, joins Section Nine his friend comes to the forefront of his mind and he can no longer ignore the case that led to Suzuki's death. Each episode was fascinating. Even more so toward the end of the anime when they start to wrap up the entertwining plot that had been going on in the backround. It get's so gripping toward the end that you simply won't be able to stop watching, especially after what happens to ... well, I can't spoil but ... let me just say that when it hit that case I cried my eyes out at the end of it.  It was quite a ride!

 

Animation:

The animation was really nicely done! I really enjoyed it and found it lovely at times even if it was a tad simplistic, it also had some disturbing scenes as well, but that was to be expected considering the plot... I cringed at some of the murder scenes because they were so well done.

Sound:

The soundtrack was good. Not fantastic, but good nothing the less. The VA's did a great job as I had no complaints on that front.

Characters:

The characters were fantastic! Especially Aoki and Maki who were the MC's. I also really loved some of the side characters ... sadly even one of the ones who was killed. T^T

Overall:

All in all, I stumbled upon this anime by chance and ended up very much enjoying the ride...

6/10 story
7/10 animation
7/10 sound
7/10 characters
7/10 overall
Merryberry's avatar
Jan 3, 2010

Intro...

The development of MRI (Memory Resonance Imaging) has led to a whole new method of investigating crimes.  Section 9 uses the brains of the deceased victims to find out exactly who or what caused the deaths of the person.

Story: 6.2

I must admit that I was intrigued by the idea of looking into peoples brains once they've died.  The concept, while incredibly unrealistic, does create a solid foundation plot which continues throughout the series.  Its strange to see how the crimes can be solved from the victims viewpoint.  While this strong permise continues throughout the series, it unfortunately does suffer from Section 9 having to investigate everything and even do the arresting.  It really does tick you off after watching a person who specialises in lip-reading dashing off heroically to solve a crime.  The ending as well was also a rather big disappointment and I wish that they'd actually done the decent thing and had a not your typical ending.  However, it does maintain enough interest to keep you watching.

Animation: 7

I must say that the animation of Himitsu: The Revelation is pretty good, with the brilliant use of dark colours and contrast to create the atmosphere of the place.  The scenes are often well chorographed to take in account what needs to be seen at the moment in time and the computer graphics while added to the flavour of the series do not impede upon the overall design.  One of the biggest annoyances within the entire show is that you really wished that the characters had a change of wardrobe.  It's rather tragic but pretty much all the characters have the same clothing day in day out and it does make you wish that they'd actually put some more effort into it.

Sound: 6.3

The music is okay, not really noticable and occasionally supports the action on scene rather well.  Personally, I didn't really like the opening or endings, I felt that they were rather boring.  Voice acting wise, it was pretty decent and didn't really have any major slip-ups along the way.

Characters: 7

There are a lot of characters in the series and not all of them are living.  Yet even the ones we see through the eyes of dead people are each given their own unique background and settings and it is perhaps this depth of character development within the series that is one of the biggest strong points.  The main characters are not overly developed, except with a noticable few who get all the high points, with the rest getting less development than the dead person.  Oh well, that's the way the series is.

Overall: 6.7

Not a series that everyone will enjoy, but certainly one that does bring some new and interesting ideas into the world of anime and if you want to see something that may sound completely far-fetched yet somehow believable, then this is certainly a series for you to watch.  Also, good for those of you who want 26 episodes of whodunnit.

6.2/10 story
8/10 animation
6.3/10 sound
7/10 characters
6.7/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful
ryanshowseason2's avatar
Jul 17, 2016

Short and simple review based on 1st episode.

Can't speak to the entire series but often the first episode is where a lot of effort, planning and budget go into.

This fell completely flat on it's face though. It fails to build any kind of suspense and dives straight into resolving any mystery it creates within 120 seconds of the conflict having been introduced. It moves incredibly fast and is supremely predictable.

Excellent concept but the execution is one of the most flawed I've ever seen. If it were even mediocre bad I wouldn't be drawn to review it based on a single episode, but this made me laugh it was so awful.

It also suffers from a syndrome that me and my girlfriend have dubbed: 10 feet tall. Where all characters are nationality wise japanese but illustrated as if they are vertically gifted as if to "compensate" for something. It's just nonsensical to make every character stand as tall as doorways, there could at least be a variety among characters.

On top of that the dialog is stilted AF

?/10 story
?/10 animation
?/10 sound
?/10 characters
2/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful
Omurqi's avatar
Jan 8, 2010

Always nice to find some surprise win in anime you almost never see anyone talk about. Also the case with this one.

It's basically a crime investigation show with a little twist: the brains of deceased people are used to look into their memories to find out who the killer was. It starts out being quite enjoyable, but not much special, with a couple of episodic stories about solving cases. However, as the story goes on, the different cases start to intertwine, plottwists that influence the entire main cast happen and most importantly, they more or less keep it from being repetitive by introducing very different crimes all the way until the end. The majority of the main cast is likable in one way or another, and most of the characters that are more in the background in the beginning get their moment later in the series.

The animation is, while not being top-notch, passable 2008 quality. The character-designs range from bishies and bishoujo’s to regular people and manage give the show a natural look. It lacks the incredibly smooth and detailed look we know from some of the better animated pieces from that year, but stands above quite a few if it comes to the designs and style.

Sound is done pretty well in Himitsu. Most of the soundtrack is very fitting and of good quality, although it is repeated a lot (with slight variations of the same piece often used). Out of the OP and ED, I liked both, but only found the OP worth listening more than once.

I’d recommend Himitsu – The Revelation to quite a lot of people. It’s something most people will enjoy. There are a couple of more gruesome scenes, but come on, that is to be expected in a 26-episode crime show ABOUT BRAINS. It’s not gory to the level of other popular shows like Elfen Lied or Higurashi anyway. Basically, if you can stomach the amount of blood in shows like CSI, you can take this without any problems. All in all, a very enjoyable ride and one of the better crime investigation shows I’ve seen (I’m usually not a big fan of these kind of shows). Think of it as Minority Report meets CSI, but with a wee bit more suspense as it goes on to get a decent idea what to expect from this.

?/10 story
?/10 animation
?/10 sound
?/10 characters
7.5/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful