valondar's avatar

valondar

  • Europe
  • Joined Sep 5, 2008
  • 37 / M

Story

In the Japanese New Wave, films such as Hara Kiri and Samurai Rebellion depicted bushido as a baseless sham and the feudal system as corrupt, cruel, decadent, and crushing people underfoot. They exposed all the supposed nobilities of the era for base lies covering even baser men.

I sound terribly pretentious, don't I? Good - because so is Shigurui. This anime takes the same blatantly pessimistic view of feudal Japan and adds in the process excessive amounts of highly disturbing violence.

Allow me to stress that: Highly disturbing. Shigurui is chock-full of savagely graphic acts right from the outset so you really must be looking for that sort of thing if you're to enjoy this anime at all. If you thought Elfen Lied was too disturbing for you - heck if you thought Elfen Lied was disturbing - then pass on. Limbs are cut, body parts are gouged, intestines come pouring from stomachs, and I'm opting not to mention the actually disturbing things in this review. Rather unpleasant, got that?

Anyway, I'm hardly suggesting that Shigurui is as nuanced as the films I compared to it - in fact it is insanely absurd. Past the ultraviolence is an aggressively morbid environment where the worst case scenario is the only option and samurai can perform superhuman feats of virtuosity (like so many of their anime counterparts, only these ones will leave you choking in revulsion). For all the absurdity, however, the tone remains deathly serious and the pace is grimly deliberate. Stylistically this is an effective choice, adding seeming depth to a relatively simple and overblown narrative.

Now there are some rather noticeable flaws in plot progression. We start off as the story-so-far, then enter an extended flashback that comprises the rest of the series and we wind up getting no ending for the set-up in the first episode or the events in the flashback. Still, I left rather satisfied - the finale brings things at least to a thematic conclusion.


Animation

Ugliness has never been this beautiful. Shigurui is gorgeously animated, composed and framed. The use of focus is delicate and measured; striking images include the diagram-like depictions of the human body and insects lazing about in the foreground. The colour palette is astonishingly grim -this is a wonderfully and morosely dark series even when just looking at it, a perpetually overcast Japan that suits the material. It goes without saying that the ultraviolence is splendidly realised - raised almost to an art. I found myself marvelling at the skill behind scenes that made me want to throw up.

The only criticism I could bring is the heavy reliance on still frames, but even then there are so many subtle movements that I would consider the animation rather exceptional - also, I considered the use of stills quite stylistically effective. Visually while this owes much to the director's earlier series Texhnolyze, Shigurui has surpassed that work aesthetically.


Sound

The music selection is simple but inspired: traditional instruments - Japanese and otherwise - backed up with occasional recourse to classical strings and deep Buddhist-esque chanting. Aurally this keeps up the self-importance (no pop ballads for this anime, no sir). A fatalistic air of inevitability is lent to sword-fights through the music - it's as cheery as a dirge. Voice acting is unmemorable but hardly overtaxed.


Characters

One thing that frequently bugs me about other disturbing anime - Elfen Lied, Gantz - is that there's a ham-fisted attempt to make the characters seem sympathetic. Be it the precociously cutesy moe-blobs in the former or the self-pitying speeches in the latter they evoke from me an eye-roll at best.

Nothing of the kind is tried for here. As I continued to watch it dawned on me that everyone is scum. Irako and Fujiki may be rivals but at different stages in the series they each perform acts so contemptible as to remove any shred of sympathy you may have had for either one; though truthfully the whole bunch are nothing more than exaggerated caricatures of samurai honour and depravity (which go hand in hand). There can be no heroes among the warrior class, just different levels of rotten bastard.

The most obviously evil figure is also the one that makes the most lasting impression: Kogan. Debauched, senile, insane, a brilliant swordsman, a rapist and incontinent, Kogan is so staggeringly monstrous in appearance it takes a stretch of the imagination to consider him human. As the head of the dojo where the samurai are all killing each other, he is the sick, warped soul of everything that is wrong with this society. He is the mad emperor who has everyone at his beck and call, able to meet out whatever twisted act he wills - and none can punish him, if anything they all seek desperately to remain in his good graces.

There are a handful of people who are not scum (i.e. women) and it's fair warning what happens to them is still pretty horrific... so those looking or expecting Shigurui to be a comeuppance fest for those who so richly deserve it will be disappointed. That said, their torment is played for horror rather than sexual gratification unlike, say, Mnemosyne. While one is more likely to reach for a bucket than a kleenex, these poor wretches are reasonably sympathetic - victims of their male-dominated environment.

Simply put these characters are shallow and viciously ridiculous but, in this kind of exaggeratedly perverse depiction of the samurai era, they rather work. Kogan in particular is a villain I won't soon forget.


Overall

This is the quintessential cult anime. Many viewers will be alienated by this bleakly misanthropic gore-fest - however, I do recommend this to those who feel they would actually enjoy the experience. I found myself completely horrified but eagerly awaiting the next episode, and in the final analysis Shigurui is easily my favourite blood-and-guts anime.

Enjoy, brave warriors - and bring your vomit bags.

7.3/10 story
8/10 animation
8/10 sound
6/10 characters
7.5/10 overall

You must be logged in to leave comments. or

PanzernKern May 20, 2014

Its a great series. Its only flaw was it didn't have a second season.

hoffstyle Aug 7, 2011

I love this anime for it's minimalist approach to the Samurai/Bushido genre. There's a lot to be said about the system the creators are trying to duplicate and I personally think they presented it well. The music, the dialogue, the character development is deliberate and to flesh the characters out in 12 episodes was no small feat.  As far as the violence and gore goes, to be honest I was not blown away. I think the gore is overhyped. Only a couple things rubbed me the wrong way: the killing of the cat and birds, and the eyeball scene. Hell, even the nipple eating scene failed to disturb me, but maybe that was because I understood why he did it.

This is a love it or hate it anime, and I definately fall into the love it category. Great review!

ShinjiTakeyama Jul 25, 2011

I don't understand the comments revolving around characters. Since when did one have to like a character to be interested in their stories? I agree, that by most standards every primary character and even many of the side characters are bastards, but that doesn't mean they have no redeeming qualities. It's obviously all just perspective differences, but I can't help have some respect for people who single mindedly devote themselves to their art, and the service of their lord. It's a completely different set of ideologies, considering how much "individuality" is stressed. They're all still different degrees of bastards really, but I think so long as one is able to separate current ideologies from their opinions of events or people in a different age, they can at least get an appreciation or understanding for them.

Anyways, great review...and interestingly different from the other editorial one. I think you managed to keep a more of an open mind in the face of what was an obvious attempt to show that things in that time were so fucked up that romanticizing it is somewhat ridiculous. You've come to understand it on a level that I think the other individual simply couldn't.

phnsr Jun 21, 2011

It's amusing. The other review for this says exactly the same things, but the scoring is opposite. Even if I did drop this after the first episode (for now, at least), I do agree with your scoring - as pertaining to animation and sound, and probably the characters too. So I guess it comes down to the gore. The other review takes the sickeningly moralistic stance on this, while you seem to like it. I can't really agree with either - with not much of a story, it basically means it's violence porn. As such, it bored me. On the other hand, I'm happy there's a series which doesn't romanticize the samurai (much like the movies you mention). As such, I feel it deserves a shot. Oh well. I guess I'll proceed to episode two.

BrainBlow Apr 15, 2011

Such heavily conflicting reviews...