The Perfect Classroom

Caela22 Jan 3, 2020

6

Interesting concept and start but poorly executed. I really enjoyed the beginning of the story but by the end I was disappointed with the conclusion (if it is one at all). ~Spoilers ahead~ The ending disappointed me due to the brother getting no punishment and being treated as a victim when he wasn't, while the He Jo got all the punishment and basically disowned. I was also confused with why she treated her brother so well, I thought it would be more interesting if it was cause of him being bullied but because he was sent to life with their mother is absurd. If he was going to become the heir to the company then her father wouldn't have sent him but He Jo instead. Even in He Jo's memories it is brought up that the father only cares about the son, so why send him off to his ex-wives house instead of raising him instead? Why didn't he fight for the son if he liked him so much? If anything, He Jo worked hard but was always hated by both parents (the mother only wanted the son because she knew she would get money compensation from the father if she kept him). I agree with the author that neither He Jo or He woo were victims and were both the bad guys but the story concluds with only He Jo being the bad guy while He Woo was seen as the victim. I have also seen other people comment on how much of a coward he was and how the ending was rushed and not up to par. Also, what happened at the previous school was not He Jo's fault but her friend's fault, but only He Jo was punished and somehow satisfies He Woos revengeful spirit. In addition, He Woo played a part in what happened to him, of course that doesn't excuse what happened to him. Overall I think the concept and the start were well done but the end was rushed and didn't sit well at all. I don't think He Jo deserved what she got, He Woo and He Jo's past was unbelievable in my eyes, and the conclusion didn't seem like one to me either. (Left me unsatisfied).

ShiroSW Jul 19, 2023

6

Starts really nice, fizzles out from the half point onwards. The characters' motivations don't make that much sense.

RavenKth23 Jan 20, 2022

5

This is a story that does not have a happy ending. Overall, it's intriguing to discover the real motives behind it all. I don't think there are any nice characters (they have been made like that) but you can know why they act like that in certain situations.