DYNASTIA's avatar

DYNASTIA

  • Joined Mar 1, 2022
  • 23

Tomie

Mar 1, 2022

I started reading Junji Ito from here, and I frankly feel like I should have just skipped this...
It's all undoubtedly very mediocre for a J-Horror saga.

Tomie seems to be a horror creature flimsily assembled from the discarded pieces of several other works, taking some bits of gothic horror, slasher flics, ghost stories, cosmic horror...
A patchwork of mismatched influences all centering on the character of Tomie, a monster with a human figure, but as irresistible as she's indestructible, a ''waifu'' Michael Myers.

For the length of its three volumes, this all remains very repetitive. The art, especially from the earlier chapters, is subpar. Every character is so inconsistent between pages, or even sometimes panels, that I've had trouble telling who is supposed to be who and what the horrible Ito wants us to see in their nonsensical actions. Tomie appears as a monster without explanation or purpose. All Tomie wants is to seduce her victims, but this inevitably leads her to be killed...

The temporality is nonexistent, some stories last for too long, where each non-recurring character tries to stop Tomie, and all inevitably fail because the narrative is too poor to allow for any development, Ito seems unable to write any humane character. The disposable victims are on a level only ever reached by b-grade ''so bad it's good'' schlock, except none of it is funny, just boring. These people stand there, encounter Tomie, try to stop her or fuck her, and get absorbed...

Tomie kills a child, Tomie vs Tomie, Tomie goes to school, Tomie on the moon...
If we think about it, it could have been worse, Ito could have given Tomie alien origins!


I think I will take my leave before I decide to tackle Uzumaki.

2/10 story
3/10 art
1/10 characters
3/10 overall

You must be logged in to leave comments. or

DYNASTIA Mar 4, 2022

@jaybugsmash

Actually, none of the characters are developed, or have any depth, so the repetition is just that, repetition...

If it makes you happy to believe this nonsense, I would have bad grace to remove the scales from your eyes as much as you take full advantage of them, even if it is a strange glorification of ignorance and of the smallest possible standard...

Ah well, it sucks, actually, so I'm not going to pretend to rate it as a good horror manga...
You're right actually for the rating, I've upgraded it to the more generous ''3'' I've already given it on other platforms, even if my better judgment seems to deem it absurd.

jaybugsmash Mar 1, 2022

I've never seen a worse take on this manga. The repetitive situations in this manga all have some different thing to them whether it be the way the guy acts or the way Tomie reacts to certain things from the boy. Lots of Ito Junji's horror manga have the repeating plothole or have something strange happen to multiple people where you see how they react. Tomie was also his first published work ever. The idea itself that you gave this a 1/10 is disgusting. Let me fix it for you. Story: 9/10: art: 10/10: Characters 9/10. Also Uzumaki is amazing so you should read it.