This is the first anime I've rated something under a 10; and it's not a typo! Even though I love harem and especially reverse harem, this one was actually pretty good though it had some....wtf parts.
Story: I rated the story 9/10. I think people can agree with me that most (I say, most) parents, especially the newly wedded ones, would not leave a teenaged girl with 13 teenaged boys! Not one, not two, 13! Plus, that's a little unrealistic! I mean, sure one was adopted and there was the triplets but still, really? And sure, who wouldn't fall in love with her? (Poor Yusuke) so, yeah, 9! But....I still kind of liked the interestingness of it
Animation: I personally like the way everything is colored and how smoothly everyone and thing moves. 10/10!
Sound: I watched the dubbed then subbed and the sounds really match and personally, the voice actors did it well! 10/10
Characters: Ok, why did I give a 9? The characters had much more personality then Diabolik Lovers and seemed more realistic, I agree. They weren't sadistic or anything like Diabolik Lovers but, I still gave a 9. I personally love their personalities and how some of them develop throughout but the parents gave it away!! Yup, they are that one score. Who just let's their teenaged daughter live with 13 teenaged boys!!?? I don't know
Overall: This is some weird stuff but I still enjoyed it some, so....9.5