pinkarray's avatar

pinkarray

  • Champaign
  • Joined Oct 24, 2011
  • 25 / F

When Marnie Was There

Jun 28, 2015

Another overrated project from Studio Ghibli. Their movies have not
been up the standards of movies such as My Neighbors the Yamadas or The
Cat Returns since 2012 with The Secret World of Arrietty. While The Cat
Returns wasn't that great, The Secret World of Arrietty was so
sentimental, it's painful. With the exception of Wind Rises, the movies
were overrated with simplistic Tale of Princess Kaguya (at the beginning,
of course). I was pretty skeptical about this one. While it started off
with a great beginning, it got boring and annoying when Sayaka showed
up. She is a forgettable character who was kind of mean, yet so nice,
she's clichéd.

Anna bothered me for some reason, it was because of her boyish clothes
but it was also something else, I don't know. Maybe she's just a
stereotypical pre-teen. Marnie was the standout character of all the
characters, she was perky, friendly, and mysterious.

Anna befriends Sayaka which drops the ball because a lot of movies have
characters befriending the clichéd nice girl. The art and animation
were still amazing as usual, but I am very disappointed in Studio
Ghibli for ending up like Pixar. The movie of course got cloying as it
went on whether it's between Anna or Sayaka or Anna and Marnie. It also
ended in a sentimental way. Maybe if they brought Hayou Miyazaki back
to directing, he would save the studio and bring it back its glory.

Also, I thought Sayaka's voice acting was a pretty bad job. The themes
just didn't click with me, it was boring and sometimes not empathetic.
Studio Ghibli tried too hard by throwing in creepy parts and an
emotional ending to be like their other movies. The creepy parts did
not blend well and ruined the pacing of the film.

6.5/10 story
10/10 animation
7/10 sound
5.5/10 characters
6/10 overall

You must be logged in to leave comments. or

KenmaKitten17 Jan 15, 2022

"Anna bothered me for some reason, it was because of her boyish clothes"

You saying that kind of offend me because Indont like girl clothes and I wear boy clothes a lot and you saying that just kind of makes it sound like tomboy are an issue and they bother you. And let Ghibli make there movies the way they want to, I haven't watched this movie yet so I came to the comment to see what other people thought about it then I just see this sad comment about how their movies have been bad and how characters bother you for kind of dumb reasons I know it just an opinion and all but some things you say like what you said about Anna can be like how people are in real life and like that kind of stuff offends them. Not trying to be rude or say anything offensive like that but I just felt like I had to talk about it. To me this is less then a review like opinion and more a a rant 

ChristinaGiann Apr 28, 2021

Τhank God ! I thought I was on my own about not getting this film ! 

AnimEva Nov 20, 2016

What? Princess Kaguya was masterful. It's one of Ghibli's best films, definitely better than The Wind Rises at least.

endallchaos Aug 18, 2016

I personally thought this is one of Ghibli's best works. I guess we just have very different taste in movies, shows etc...

boogiepopkol Jan 12, 2016

How did you give it a 6 overall rating? when you gave it a 7,10,9,7 rating. It seems it would be more like an 8 overall rating .