Candydr0ps, You're saying: In Shippuden, Karui is valid, moral, and correct, in hitting Naruto when he asks for forgiveness on behave of Sasuke. And that it wasn't right for the author, readers, and other characters to demonize her.
MateausCarvalho590 is saying: Even though her motivations were right, they were wrong because she overdid it, thus making her a bad person; as being overemotional isn't a valid reason to do what she did. Also, her being guilty doesn't make her a good person. Ending with, being taught to act couldn't be what made her act this way, she had to have been born with these overemotional issues.
I'm responding with: Her motivations were 100% justified. If he wasn't a ninja, she probably wouldn't have beat him so badly and if she wanted to actually harm him she had more abilities to use rather than simply hitting him, so she knew what was going on.
Guilt is, by definition, what makes a person "good"; a bad person is declared as a bad person because they don't feel remorse for the actions that they take which hurt others.
Lastly, you can definitely be taught to never hold back your emotions or actions, that's actually what discipline literally means: "train someone to obey rules or a code of behaivior".
She felt remorse, she's a good person. She overreacted, she feels bad about it. It's the ninja world, and if punching someone a few times makes you a bad person, then Gara, Sasuke, Sakura, Chiyo (old lady who meets Kakashi in the Desert Village), Tsunade, and a handful of others should also be considered bad people. And it seems that it was all forgiven, so no harm no foul. I don't think she's demonized by anyone in the Leaf Village anymore.
I understand very well what you said, but even though she has the right motivations for everything you said, she also has very strong wrong motivations, because the fact that overdoing it for the right can make her motivations and morals even worse, and also because of high levels of euphoria, impulsiveness, emotional imbalance, excessive proactivity, etc. And the reason why Karui is so bad and worse, not because of its own guilt, but because of its functions of conscience (which are: high or low simplicity or emotional complexity of incomplete or complete levels, simple or complex attitudes and actions, etc).
And even if she didn’t have these complicated and difficult moments, like the situation she’s going through, the sense that she explains how she was probably taught and other things, she would still have these awareness functions (like high emotional complexity at full levels, emotional imbalance, excessive proactivity, high levels of euphoria, impulsiveness, etc.), due to the fact that she was born with these functions.
When you're saying that, you're talking about Karui from Boruto, not Karui from Naruto Shippuden. At first, she was extremely annoying due to her emotional imbalance and excessive proactivity, but it's okay that she later married Chouji and she stopped being like that and changed completely. But it would be a matter of custom.
You must be logged in to leave comments. Login or sign up today!
You Really 69 O.O
Candydr0ps, You're saying:
In Shippuden, Karui is valid, moral, and correct, in hitting Naruto when he asks for forgiveness on behave of Sasuke. And that it wasn't right for the author, readers, and other characters to demonize her.
MateausCarvalho590 is saying:
Even though her motivations were right, they were wrong because she overdid it, thus making her a bad person; as being overemotional isn't a valid reason to do what she did. Also, her being guilty doesn't make her a good person. Ending with, being taught to act couldn't be what made her act this way, she had to have been born with these overemotional issues.
I'm responding with:
Her motivations were 100% justified. If he wasn't a ninja, she probably wouldn't have beat him so badly and if she wanted to actually harm him she had more abilities to use rather than simply hitting him, so she knew what was going on.
Guilt is, by definition, what makes a person "good"; a bad person is declared as a bad person because they don't feel remorse for the actions that they take which hurt others.
Lastly, you can definitely be taught to never hold back your emotions or actions, that's actually what discipline literally means: "train someone to obey rules or a code of behaivior".
She felt remorse, she's a good person. She overreacted, she feels bad about it. It's the ninja world, and if punching someone a few times makes you a bad person, then Gara, Sasuke, Sakura, Chiyo (old lady who meets Kakashi in the Desert Village), Tsunade, and a handful of others should also be considered bad people. And it seems that it was all forgiven, so no harm no foul. I don't think she's demonized by anyone in the Leaf Village anymore.
Idk, Fugaku is a masculine and stern type of cute
I understand very well what you said, but even though she has the right motivations for everything you said, she also has very strong wrong motivations, because the fact that overdoing it for the right can make her motivations and morals even worse, and also because of high levels of euphoria, impulsiveness, emotional imbalance, excessive proactivity, etc. And the reason why Karui is so bad and worse, not because of its own guilt, but because of its functions of conscience (which are: high or low simplicity or emotional complexity of incomplete or complete levels, simple or complex attitudes and actions, etc).
And even if she didn’t have these complicated and difficult moments, like the situation she’s going through, the sense that she explains how she was probably taught and other things, she would still have these awareness functions (like high emotional complexity at full levels, emotional imbalance, excessive proactivity, high levels of euphoria, impulsiveness, etc.), due to the fact that she was born with these functions.
When you're saying that, you're talking about Karui from Boruto, not Karui from Naruto Shippuden. At first, she was extremely annoying due to her emotional imbalance and excessive proactivity, but it's okay that she later married Chouji and she stopped being like that and changed completely. But it would be a matter of custom.