TheTacticianMusician's avatar

TheTacticianMusician

  • Tennessee, USA
  • Joined Nov 17, 2013
  • 26 / M

Hi! I'm The Tactician. But more importantly, I'm a Musician. I'm also often referred to by my shortened name "TactiMuse". You can call me either, cause they're both correct. Tactician, Tacti, Tac, and Muse can also work.

I got into anime late. It wasn't until my freshman year (2010) that I was actually introduced to it and even knew that it was considered its own media genre. And actually it wasn't until another year after (2011), that I actually watched a full anime of my own volition... which is probably one I shouldn't have watched at that age... Anyway after that, ever since about 2013, I was always on an anime hunt... that is, whenever I found time to. There was a big gap between mid 2014 and early 2015 where I couldn't watch anything, which left me behind for a while, as I'd normally watch at least 2 shows every quarter.

Bringing me to today, I somehow still seem to successfully watch at least 10 shows per year, which sounds like not a lot, but as a full-time courier driver, I find it difficult to make time to watch anime, since I also love gaming as well. Still, I don't watch anime just to brag about my watched catalog. I don't try to watch as many shows as possible that come out each season. I go one at a time, watching what I want when I want.

I will however admit I'm pleased to know I've seen enough shows to have a diverse favorites list in most categories. So, allow me to list some of those (these are all subject to change):

Top 7 Anime (in general):

#7. Re:ZERO

#6. Monster

#5. Sound! Euphonium

#4. Mai-Hime

#3. Fate/Zero

#2. Death Note

#1. Attack on Titan

Before you continue on, if you want to see my reasoning for these placements, check This List, which is still being filled in as again, I have difficulty finding time to edit my opinions, but the order is my honest opinion. Also this list includes EVERY anime I've seen, which means if you're favorite is not there, then I haven't seen it.

Top 7 Protagonists:

#7. Nadie (El Cazador De La Bruja)

#6. Senkuu (Dr. Stone)

#5. Subaru Natsuki (Re:ZERO)

#4. Dr. Tenma (Monster)

#3. Mai Tokiha (Mai-Hime)

#2. Erin Yeager (Attack on Titan)

#1. Light Yagami (Death Note)

I know I'm missing a lot of obvious characters from shows like Fullmetal Alchemist, Code Geass, Evangelion, Cowboy Beebop, the OG Big 3 (etc.), but as stated before, there are a lot of classic anime I still haven't seen.

Top 7 Villains:

#7. Tsukasa (Dr. Stone)

#6. Momobami (Kakegurui)

#5. Elsa (Re:ZERO)

#4. The Marleyans (Attak on Titan)

#3. Kire Kotomine (Fate/Series)

#2. Altair (Re:CREATORS)

#1. Yohan Libert (Monster)

This is not an "Antagonist" list. My definition of "villain" is a little more specific than "antagonist", and not every antagonist is a villain, but vice versa, not every villain is necessarily the antagonist.

My qualifacations for a villain:
- Character must do objectively bad or evil things
- Character must either have an idealistic or objectively evil goal.
- Character must not be the protagonist

For example, L from Death Note is the main antagonist, but he's not the villain. He's not objectively evil or despicable. An example of the inverse would be Alyssa from Mai-Hime. She is not the antagonist, but she does do objectively evil things pretty indiscriminately for "evil" reasons. Also, for me, the villain cannot be the protagonist, so unfortunately Light from Death Note is also disqualified.

As you may have noticed, I have certain methods of putting emphasis on specific words, names, and titles. I do this to emphasize to readers exactly what I'm talking about and whether it's related to the topic at hand or just referencing something else. Here is what it all means:

ALL CAPS - General emphasis, onomatopoeia or exclamatory language.

Italics - Anime Titles [Example: Death NoteFate/ZeroRe:CREATORS]

Bold - Character Names (on topic) [Example: Light YagamiNagiJabami]

Bold Underline - Staff Names, Usernames, and other Real People's names [Example: Hiroyuki SawanoTheTacticianMusicianCarrie Underwood]

"Quotations" - Terms, Locations, and Lines, within discussion of a specific anime [Example: "HiME"; "Holy Grail War"; "Titans"]

Underline - Titles for media outside of anime titles [Example: Ensei; Harry PotterSuper Smash Bros.]

ALL BOLD CAPS - Character Names for off-topic or 3rd-party media [Example: YOHAN LIBERT, when talking about Death Note]

What I Review:

This might seem redundant, but in all seriousness, there are certain things that I refuse to Rate and/or Review on this website. It all depends on if they fall under the following categories:

Subsequent Seasons

Sequel Movies

My Review Score & Ranking System:

I have TWO different formulas for scoring anime, both of which prioritize Story & Characters, and then combines the Sound & Animation scores into a single category called "Atmosphere". I have 1 formula for when the Sound & Animation are not very important to the show, and another scoring formula for when they are much more important. An easy example of the difference is for anime about musicians or artists. Obviously in a show about an artist or musician, the Sound & Animation are of much more importance than your average Psychological or Action anime.

How that formulates into the actual scores is like this:

The Substance System: [S x 4.5 + C x 4.5 + (m + a = A / 2 + ] = V 

The Plot System: [S x 5 + C x 4 + (m + a = A 2 + ] = V

The Cast System: [S4C x 5 + (m + a = A 2 + ] = V 

_________________

The Style System: [3.5 + C x 3.5 + (x 1.5 + a 1.5 A) + ? ] = 

The Good-Ear System: [3.5C x 3.5 + (m x 2a = A) + ? ] = 

The Eye-Candy System: [3.5 + C x 3.5 + (m a x 2 = A) + ? ] = 

For the first system, which will be used for 90% of the anime I review, you basically multiply the Story (S) & Character (C) scores by 4.5, separately. Then add the Sound (m) & Animation (a) scores to get double the Atmosphere (A) score. The () is for a 3rd but separate Atmosphere category I call "General Effect", which is an invisible score of -1, 0, +1, or +2, which can subtract or add an extra point or two, for either going above and beyond in the attention to detail, or inversely being lifeless and bland, or just being mediocre. This number will be in the Atmosphere score, but you won't see me add it anywhere.

The other 3 are variants on the "Stylized" system. Both Story & Characters categories account for 35% of the scoring, and Atmosphere accounts for 30% of the full score. The difference being that sometimes: either the Sound or Animation will count for two-thirds of the Atmosphere score, which would amount to 20% and 10% of the overall review scroe. Other times they will both be counted for HALF of the Atmosphere scoring, which means they would account for 15% of the overall review score. In all three cases, the Atmosphere is still less important than the Story & Characters, but is still important enough that it's almost a third of the whole score.

Now as for the ranks themselves, instead of final scores, I essentially give viewers my thoughts on how I believe they should aproach a certain show.


(0.1 - 0.9)
"Break it"
Break it


(2.0 - 2.9)
"Forget it"
Forget it

⭐★
(3.0 - 3.9)
"Avoid it"

⭐⭐
(4.0 - 4.9)
"Skip it"

⭐⭐★
(5.0 - 5.9)
"Risk it"

⭐⭐⭐
(6.0 - 6.9)
"Try it"

⭐⭐⭐★
(7.0 - 7.9)
"Watch it"

⭐⭐⭐⭐
(8.0 - 8.9)
"Finish it"

⭐⭐⭐⭐★
(9.0 - 9.7)
"Binge it"

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
(9.8 - 9.9)
"Marathon it"

Life on anime

  • 43 Minutes
  • 0 Hours
  • 3 Days
  • 0 Weeks
  • 2 Months
  • 0 Years

Anime ratings

  • 5
  • 4.5
  • 4
  • 3.5
  • 3
  • 2.5
  • 2
  • 1.5
  • 1
  • 0.5

117 total

Life on manga

  • 0 Minutes
  • 0 Hours
  • 0 Days
  • 0 Weeks
  • 0 Months
  • 0 Years

What?! No manga ratings?

Encourage TheTacticianMusician to add some by leaving a comment below!

I adore these characters

See all loved characters

I'm not a fan of these characters

See all hated characters

Comments

You must be logged in to leave comments. Login or sign up today!

ReviewBonfire Aug 28, 2021

Ah, sorry i somehow didnt check the date of the Review, makes sense then. Many of my reviews were outdated as well before I deleted them.

Did you rewatch the Anime recently? I watched the Anime 4 days ago and read the Manga afterwards, just because I was curiour.

The Manga had faster pacing (around 8 Episodes long) if it was animated this way, and totally rushed ending. The anime was also stretched and empty. I still give credits for the good soundtracks and the actually concept of the Plot, it was bad used but the idea was solid. The author was missing experience and skills at this point.

ReviewBonfire Aug 27, 2021

Seriously your 11 Eyes Review killed me. This is some lvl of overscoring a bad show to beyond