ReviewBonfire's avatar

ReviewBonfire

  • Germany
  • Joined Apr 12, 2020
  • 28 / M

Hello and welcome if someone got lost here. Either to discuss something with me or to throw salt at me.

Myy name is Alex and I am now older than I would like to admit, but I still watch anime regularly and read manga from time to time. I have been doing this for 16 years with its ups and downs.
I used to be kind of a "weeb" who thought there were hardly any bad anime and they were all good in their way, so I just threw around 10/10* ratings.
This has changed more often over the years, so I always thought I had discovered a better form of ratings. Now I am trying to write my reviews as neutral as possible and give points accordingly, I have my point system which I follow.

Now the question, why do I do that?

Of course, everyone can like the anime he wants to like, this is up to everyone. I also like some anime that I have rated very low, because they are bad and unimaginative, but have met my taste. So remember, a bad anime doesn't have to be cursed, it can be entertaining too.

The problem though is that most of the community either throws around positive ratings and always thinks every other anime is a masterpiece. And the other half rates everything as low as possible because they disliked the hype.
I don't want to make myself special or claim "I'm the only one who's objective", I'm not. I'm just trying to be as neutral as I can be so I can be fair to anime and manga that deserves it and critical of those that need improvement.

What is my goal?

There is none, I like writing reviews so I can do two things at once. Also, many people have written to me over the years for discussions, which has been interesting. Usually, these ended well and you either convinced others or gained new views. Ultimately, one of my reviews will reach people and they will either understand my take on it or not.


Note, I can also get salty so don't be surprised if I throw feces back at you.

 

1⭐Disaster. To go down that far, you have to make one mistake after another without making up for it with positive points.
2⭐Not worth seeing. A work that failed in almost every area.
3⭐Weak. Such series have almost nothing to speak of, but you can still watch them somehow.
4⭐ Below average. Titles that have a lot of wasted potential.
5⭐ Average. Perfectly balanced, as all things should be.
6⭐Series that can be called "above average" through their implementation.
7⭐Very interesting series that cannot be at the top, but are very well remembered.
8⭐Great anime that stand out from the crowd. They are lacking in some areas, but these works will never be forgotten.
9⭐ An unparalleled top title in every aspect. Will stand above almost all other works in the future and many will talk about them.
10⭐A title that could come closest to the "word" masterpiece. Such works are almost flawed and have shown great quality in every area.

Intermediate evaluations such as 5.5⭐ / 10 ⭐
show for me only that the work was able to stand out from the average through a few special events or scenes, but could never prove itself further.

And noted, there are no differences between the genre focus.
A comedy can be on the same level as an extremely difficult story flick. Each work has its own genre approaches and must be assessed and judged according to its own standards.

 

 

Life on anime

  • 29 Minutes
  • 2 Hours
  • 5 Days
  • 0 Weeks
  • 6 Months
  • 0 Years

Anime ratings

  • 5
  • 4.5
  • 4
  • 3.5
  • 3
  • 2.5
  • 2
  • 1.5
  • 1
  • 0.5

349 total

Life on manga

  • 55 Minutes
  • 5 Hours
  • 1 Day
  • 2 Weeks
  • 0 Months
  • 0 Years

Manga ratings

  • 5
  • 4.5
  • 4
  • 3.5
  • 3
  • 2.5
  • 2
  • 1.5
  • 1
  • 0.5

31 total

I adore these characters

See all loved characters

I'm not a fan of these characters

See all hated characters

Comments

You must be logged in to leave comments. or today!

James4life May 16, 2024

Repetition with powerup is one of issues with FT. Although Erza still had quite good fights till the last arcs and in some of them she struggled alone before joining other FT members as team to win in the end. 

Ovas were purely for fanservice and most are noncanon. 

All in all, Erza still is one of best written female characters in animes  orphaned, enslaved as child then went on to become selfless, kind and forgiving and emotionally strong.  This trait is missing in many characters who become permanetly emotionally and mentally crippled after traumatic childhood. Take Mikasa Ackerman, Asuka Soryu as example. And Erza had more traumatic childhood as orphaned, enslaved girl. 

Mikasa has no emotional identity, sense of purpose, goal of her own. She spends much of story having parasitic emotional dependence on Eren after she was saved by Eren in childhood. She never became character of her own despite the fact that she was supposed to be one of main characters. 

James4life May 15, 2024

Flanderization of shounen characters is a problem across the board but even then i must disgaree on Erza. Even Nakama powerup of FT don't change character's broader traits such as its past, depth and development.

An orphan, enslaved as child, her parents tried to kill her yet she went on to become kind, selfless,loyal. Despite having traumatic past, she became mentally and emotionally strong, a trait many characters with similar background lack.

Monstrous Physical strength.Child prodigy.Hot.Beautiful.

Very mature and slow burning romance. Loyal to one man- childhood lover( he has winter soldier type situation) despite spending decade away from him. Stood by him through thick and thin.

kittykitty Apr 14, 2024

Well I think we should agree to disagree... But I can totally agree with you on Asuna Yuuki lmfao 

kittykitty Apr 11, 2024

 Natsu as a dislike character is a crime. 

ReviewBonfire Dec 19, 2023

Remember, Erza is the worst Female Anime Character ever.