Hi, I watch anime too.
Check out my tierlist, you might find some titles you haven't watched yet.
These are my milestones:
1st anime - DARLING in the FRANXX
100th anime - Grimms Notes the Animation
These are my usual ratings:
10-8★ - Top tier anime
7-6★ - Pretty okay
5-4★ - Yep, that was an anime
3★ - "I want to watch something just to waste some time"
2-1★ - Producers were high on crack when they made this
0★ - OVA's, music videos, ect.*
(* - I don't rate these)