Surgical Swordsman

Shiha97 Jul 5, 2020

3

This story had the potential, but sadly it didn't meet my expectations. The story at times is confusing with no clear direction, like its been hastily made. The genre is all over the place, I'm caught up and I still don't know whats the genre supposed to be. MC is poorly introduced, like no solid backstory what so ever. I wanna emphasize this doesn't have a clear goal, its like those writers just wanted to fool around with a creative idea. If someone took it and made it with some effort I bet it would rank a lot higher than right now. I totally agree with its ranking. Its short, boring,  and confusing. Wasted time tbh. P.S if the writer reads this I wanna say please read properly made manga before trying, your work is a complete mess but kudos on creativity. 

PZcolo Aug 30, 2019

2

A mess of forced situations where the MC has little say and he just goes with whatever the others push uppon him. The "story" if you can call it that, is a mess that progresses with no direction so far, though to be honest, this is common in cultivation stories, they are simply so long that the start of the stories are usually either ridiculous power-ups or this kind of undefined slow world building. I have to say though that this one does it worse than most, it does little sense and the characters actions are hardly realistic. So yeah, it once the MC starts to get strong it may change but 30 ch in andhe hasn't even started to train for it and the start of a story is one of the most important parts of it, in my experience there have been very few mangas/manhuas that started badly and got good. Also, it does all this by not taking itself seriously, does not explaining much and uses bad comedy as an excuse for lack of sense and cohesiveness. And to top it off, tha author has a bad sense of humor, well I correct myself, has a kids oriented sense of humor, I guess kids in puberty and their teens might enjoy the jokes. SPOILER from saving a girl he's captured, has his family put in danger: from saving the village chief he's treated as a usless person and given the most precarious life style: from saving another girl, she asks him to be his master after which he's thrown in prison by her, forced a weird drink and forced to be the newly revealed princess' master (by the way, martial arts are forbidden by the emperor). And the MC just goes with the flow...

MajorFluffyBacon May 25, 2019

6

Disclaimer i only read up to  Chapter 14.  So far the only reason this is classified as a time-travel is to explain why hes good at being a doctor/surgeon other than that it doesnt seem relevent. This seems to be a typical martial arts type Manhua where the MC is weak and then starts to cultivate and ima assume that he gets OP since the title  is Surgical Swordsman. The art is pretty good and fight scene are not bad. If i could have stayed with it, I probably would have enjoyed it ;HOWEVER, i just couldnt get over the translation. its not so terrible but i just couldnt continue on reading it. It annoyed me too much. If you can ignore it or the translation doesnt bother you then you should enjoy this.