Miss Guillotine

OneEyeMonkey May 21, 2021

8

Story starts with MC beeing buillied by her classm8 then one day MCs sister gets killed and she founds out it was her classmate who was bulling her so she decide to take revange on her and her group. The only porblem was that all the bad girl bullies were some kinda of magical girls that were protecting the world and getting piad by goverment and noone went againts then. The porblem with this was that it was kinda pointless over the top thing puttted into this story. They could be just normal highschool girls. Also in this world there are monsters but they dont do anything in story basicly only thing they do is that they exist so that magical girls thing could be putted into the story. First half i was always asking my self why they puttted it in here. But at the end i was like oh ok it make some sence. I read this whole in one day pasing was great tesion was felt in every chapter. The only thing they could do better was better set up for ending that felt kinda rushed. But the thing i love about this the most was that i couldnt predict what will happen next (at the end i oculd but first 40 chapters i had no clue and the character i thought will be main villan was not ). Characters to me all the bad girls felt kinda same. Some of magical girls had good introduction and fleshbacks and some did not. Ice girl was way too rushed and it felt like author did forget about her ... But MC was great liked her a lot becouse she actually used her brain what is kinda unique in mangas these days.

Powexistent Apr 14, 2024

7

The story’s initial season (Chapter 1-38) provided a revenge plot with an exceptionally cathartic impact. Callie’s character development kept me captivated, and the well-paced storytelling led me to finish the story in one sitting. Unfortunately, the story seriously declined in quality after the first season. The author thought it was somehow wise to provide the magical girls with a backstory and attempt to justify their sadistic and megalomaniac tendencies. However, this only resulted in creating plot holes and diminishing reader engagement from the initial season. For instance, there was a huge plot hole that I couldn’t overlook. Despite my attempts to continue reading, I eventually had to stop because it continued to bother me. If you’re interested, it’s the fact that the reveal that Julie chose/created the magical girls means that she knowingly made Sue a magical girl after she killed the girl originally chosen. As in, Julie chose someone she KNEW was a murderer to take the place of someone who was meant to protect people. I found that so jarring that literally nothing that came afterwards made any sense to me. If your interest in reading the story, I would recommend you stop after chapter 38, where the story should have ended after the death of Sue.

Curiousmadra Sep 28, 2020

6

Ladies and gents, we have another darkish magical girl series but this time they are bullies as well as "mean girls" murderers. It's also in desperate need of the horror genre as "Magica Madoka" because like I felt there was something missing while reading this manhwa. Don't get me wrong, the art is amazing and it's interesting to see the story about a "from weak to strong" girl getting revenge on magical girls for her sisters death. However I just felt it needed to be a lot more edgier within each characters development, I just felt they were rather rushed, forgotten about and confusing. Maybe I'm the one who's missing a point but it's just I felt when I read this over 89 chapter manhwa. I recommend people who are fans of the magical girl genre to give this a go. It is different but I wouldn't personally call it better than Magica Madoka or Sailor Moon....