Light and Shadow - Reviews

Alt title: Bitgwa Geurimja

Light and Shadow
loveloveshow's avatar
Oct 28, 2020

The female lead was raped by the male lead by chapter 3 and then goes on to treat her horribly. I do not understand why people like this manga. Ruined my mood.

1/10 story
1/10 art
1/10 characters
1/10 overall
Lupa's avatar
Jun 14, 2019

If you like a strong female MC, then this webcomic is for you. Edna initially seemed like she was going to be a weak character who gets pushed around by the circumstances and people around her, but with every chapter that went by, she became more badass and confident. I loved her! Edna and Eli make a great, well-balanced power couple, and their relationship with each other becomes very heartfelt.

The plot was good - good pacing and a nice mix of both romance and action. Enough plot twists to keep things from getting stale or predictable . I've seen this webcomic labelled as "smut", but aside from a few brief scenes at the beginning there isn't much content that would fall into that category. The emphasis of this webcomic is definitely the plot and character development, not fan service.

*minor spoilers* There were a few minor things that kept me from rating this webcomic as a "9" - the main one being the start of the relation ship btwn Edna and Eli. It was hard for me to like Eli after he forced himself on Edna on the first day that they met. For a quasi-medieval setting, yes, that is a realistic scenario. And yes, he eventually does apologize. But as a woman in the 21st century, it was hard for me to move past that when the author began to develop his character more. The transition of their relationship from "you are the guy who basically raped me" to "oh actually I really love you a lot" felt forced and unnatural to me. 

8/10 story
8/10 art
8/10 characters
8/10 overall
natanickii's avatar
Nov 9, 2020

I don't understand how this is so hyped. The characters are very typical and their relationship is so shallow. It's just that they're both attractive and she's nice and he's unused to nice people. Very typical. They hardly have any moments where they actually have a heart to heart. There's also a rape scene that's never addressed. The greater plot is bland and simple.

Let me repeat, I don't understand how this is so hyped. The art is spectacular but everything else is average or below. 

4/10 story
10/10 art
2/10 characters
2/10 overall
RenxHinaya's avatar
Mar 16, 2019

It has these

  1. A strong female lead
  2. Neat romance (after a few chapters)
  3. A lot about kingdoms
  4. Good artwork
  5. Slight, like very slight smut... only towarss the beginning
  6. Good plot
  7. Good side characters
  8. Promising ending

So, initially even though female lead seems weak and dumb, you will tend to love her later. It is not your usual manga where the man aids his wife, or his wife aids him

It ia a near line of clear support from both parties later...initially it may seem misogynistic and very weak. Later, you will like it.

Since it is incomplete, you may not wanna pick it up. But it is worth the wait for every week.

Art work is not extravagant. It is simple but conveys all. It gets a little confusing as to the back stories...that is still confusing for to whose son is who, who is protecting who and stuff

This part also gets a little boring...for me in my case since am not a fan of realllllly political situations

9/10 story
9/10 art
?/10 characters
9/10 overall
MilkyMartha's avatar
Sep 11, 2019

i thought the this manwhua was an amazing action romance with so many emotions . The backstory of this world was drizzled in throughout the story and was often shown not told , the characters were also developed slowly and in a sensible manner . The action and romance was thrilling , and the art style totally complimented the story . The plot was so interesting and I couldn’t stop reading after the first few chapters , it made me so happy , sad and excited and couldn’t wait to see what happened next . The story wasn’t some recycled cliche garbage but rather it’s own unique and enthralling tale . This is a must read.

10/10 story
10/10 art
10/10 characters
10/10 overall