Ingoshima

sothis Sep 6, 2023

1

I refuse to rate something higher than a 1 if the driving aspect of the plot is to glorify and showcase gang rape, over and over, by either a mangaka or artist that clearly has a rape fantasy going on. Hopefully this review will deter some readers who have a similar problem with this sort of glorification. People crashland on an island, the wild natives go after them. Whatever, standard/boring trope, and yes, the men (and some of the women - but not many) get killed in gory ways, standard fare for stuff like Kichikujima and nbd on my end as I love dark genres and horror. But when a major plot point that they keep coming back to is groups of men raping all the women, it's sickening and difficult to believe anyone can rate this highly. They get raped en masse by a massive crowd because the leader lets them, they get hung up and raped on demand for any of the slaves they have captured and do manual labor, etc. The "lucky" ones get taken as a harem for the leader who rapes them whenever he wants, and of course, the women who have been there for awhile are super into it with stockholm syndrome, because of course they are. Or the ones that get raped by their classmates because the incel who has the water decides why not demean and violate his crush in exchange for sharing it with the rest of the group cause he can't get her attention irl otherwise, while she lays there with dead eyes. Fantastic. As if this isn't bad enough that the plot just keeps coming back to it, the assaults and the women in general are drawn like this is full on H. They're constantly naked with conical boobs that swing in different directions as they're getting assaulted, they have constant alien-like ahegao faces, etc.  Dropped this after a few dozen chapters, hoping it would get better, after yet-the-next gang raping happened. Vile. 

JangGwangnam Jun 3, 2019

4

For starters it's cliche asf. Many generic troups are reused; hell even my friend (who's got actual autism) has written a similar story thats got more depth than this sh*t. Main plot: Random storm in the middle of the sea hits ship hard and it breaks -> They end up on a island with inhabitants that sacrifice people -> Aim is to steal stolen fuel from inhabitant stronghold and get off the island by sailing through the calm sea after the storm  ^^^That's essentially the plot. To thicken it the author added a childhood friend crush pretext consisting of a (one dimensional) girl and a nerdy kid (MC) that's good with tech. Kid tries to save childhood friend (who's very very stupid and again one dimensional asf) who kept trying to save her bff (she got rap*d later on - thank god for that) and was captured by the inhabitants. Furthermore she happens to be crowned as the 'chosen one' by the voodoo witch and the inhabitants look after her. In the process of saving her while lacking much preparation MC gets caught by enemy but saved then knocked out by a ex-American female soldier (maybe fat man and little boy got into the japs heads too much) with big tits (btw all the girls got big tits in this manga, dont ask why probs fan service) who is pissed off at him for wreaking her plans but later lets him convince her into letting him join in on the operation. (this is up to CH 21). If you haven't noticed by this point there's literally not much depth or worth within this manga at all. If there's any good thing I have to point out then it has to be the artwork, it's literally (to me atleast) stunning - nearly Boichi 'Sun Ken Rock' level good - which is why I read it up to CH 21 (though I will be dropping it here since I got other bookmarks to go through). I hope my review enlightened you enough to not read this. Therefore I wish you a good day ;).

Naitred Dec 21, 2023

2.5

Ok this manga is really rubbish, I was hoping to see a survival story and then have a trashy manga that goes from horror to battle shonen we don't know why, credit also goes to the protagonist, one of the most annoying ever encountered in a manga !