I Got Caught Up In a Hero Summons, but the Other World was at Peace! - Recommendations

Alt title: Yuusha Shoukan ni Makikomareta kedo, Isekai wa Heiwa deshita

I Got Caught Up In a Hero Summons, but the Other World was at Peace!

If you're looking for anime similar to I Got Caught Up In a Hero Summons, but the Other World was at Peace!, you might like these titles.

The Fruit of Evolution: Before I Knew It My Life Had It Made

The Fruit of Evolution: Before I Knew It My Life Had It Made

Seiichi Hiiragi is at the bottom of his school's social pecking order, but one day, he and his entire school are upended when everyone in the school is transported into another world. Seiichi finds himself alone and approached by a gorilla, who instead of attacking him, proposes to him. At the moment that Seiichi thinks that "I guess a gorilla is fine too," they find the Fruit of Evolution, and when they eat it, their lives are suddenly changed once again.

I agree

The Saint's Magic Power is Omnipotent 2nd Season

The Saint's Magic Power is Omnipotent 2nd Season

The second season of The Saint's Magic Power is Omnipotent.

I agree

The Saint's Magic Power is Omnipotent

The Saint's Magic Power is Omnipotent

Sei, a 20-year-old office worker, is whisked away to a whole new world. Unfortunately for Sei, the ritual that summoned her—meant to produce a “Saint” who would banish the dark magic—brought two people over instead of one. And everyone prefers the second girl over Sei?! But this is just fine by Sei, who leaves the royal palace to set up shop making potions and cosmetics with her newfound magic. Business is booming, and this might not be such a bad life, after all…as long as her supposed Sainthood doesn’t come back to haunt her.

I agree

New The Fruit of Evolution: Before I Knew It My Life Had It Made

Summoned to Another World for a Second Time

Summoned to Another World for a Second Time

There was once a hero who was summoned to another world, and he saved that world. However, the man was caught in a "trap" and was forcibly returned to his original world. On top of that, he had to start over as a baby… This is the story of a crazy journey in another world where a former hero who was reincarnated into a slightly gloomy high school student is "resummoned" back to that same world! There's a lot of room to work with when it's the second time, huh♪

I agree

The Twelve Kingdoms

The Twelve Kingdoms

Yohko is nothing but ordinary. Throughout her life she has been considered an outcast, especially with a hair color not native to many in Japan, bright red. Things change for Yohko when a mysterious man named Keiki arrives and claims that she is his empress. Yohko and two friends are then taken through a vortex, and then abandoned.. in a world of demons and magic.

I agree

Dahlia in Bloom

Dahlia in Bloom

After dying of overwork in Japan, Dahlia is reborn into a world filled with magic. Raised by a master of magical toolmaking, she develops a passion for the craft and becomes engaged to her father’s apprentice. Before her father can see her wed, however, he suddenly passes away. As if this weren’t enough, on the day before their wedding, her fiancé announces that he’s in love—but not with her! Dahlia finally realizes she needs to live for herself. She vows to be her own woman from now on and devote herself to her craft, even if it’s not quite the quiet life she was hoping for! From a chance encounter with a knight to starting her own company, there are challenges aplenty on the horizon. But this young craftswoman is no longer a shrinking violet—she’s Dahlia, and she’s ready to bloom.

I agree

Life With an Ordinary Guy Who Reincarnated Into a Total Fantasy Knockout

Life With an Ordinary Guy Who Reincarnated Into a Total Fantasy Knockout

Childhood friends Tachibana Hinata and Jinguji Tsukasa were living the everyday life of office workers. Then, on the way home from a mixer, they were sent flying into another world by a mysterious being. Once there, Jinguji sees his best friend has been turned into a beautiful blonde-haired, blue-eyed girl...?! The adorableness of Tachibana’s female form completely flummoxes Tachibana. But these two are each others’ best friends. To keep their relationship from being destroyed, they must defeat the Demon Lord as quickly as possible and return to their original forms.

I agree

Arifureta: From a Detour to the World's Strongest

Arifureta: From a Detour to the World's Strongest

Hajime, Yue, Shea, Tio, Kaori and Yue take a detour to learn more about each other, their outfits, and Japanese otaku slang.

I agree

Loner Life in Another World

Loner Life in Another World

Haruka is just your average high school loner, minding his own business and keeping to himself as he makes it through his high school career, until one day—he's suddenly sent to another world alongside the rest of his class! Before he knows it, he’s face-to-face with the god of this new world, who presents him with a list of cheat skills to choose from…but there’s a catch. It’s first come first served, and his classmates have already beaten him to the punch. Haruka has to make do with what he can get as he navigates his way through this brave new world, all while flying solo!

I agree