GATE: Where the JSDF Fought - Reviews

Alt title: Gate: Jieitai Kanochi nite, Kaku Tatakaeri

GATE: Where the JSDF Fought
NightKnightMike's avatar
Sep 14, 2015

This anime is insanely fun to watch and read, if you want more detail read it if you want action watch it. I highly suggest this to guys that like funny, awesome and interesting anime/manga like this where you have people with guns fighting fantasy themed enemies. Because seriously who wouldnt want to see a Dragon shot by a AA and Rockets? Who wouldnt want to see those silly Knights attempt to charge are base while hit with mines, artillery and snipers?

10/10 story
10/10 art
10/10 characters
10/10 overall
Earlos's avatar
Dec 16, 2022

Honestly the only good thing to see is exactly the reason this attracted me (as the first manga i ever read), the geopolitics and how they go about the "what if" senario are well executed, story is def the best part about the manga from what i remember (although the part with the 13yo sherry is goofy, stupid and throws off the seriousness of the story)

the manga is ofc one big self stroke by the author or propaganda or both, some of the statements might be so bad it actually gets annoying and cringe, keep that in mind ig

art is ok i guess, some panels are beautiful (mostly military) but rest are below average in how clean they are (god forbid you read a low quality scan), the charcter design is badass sometimes pretty eh or awful most of the time, generally they go with casual clothes which i like

i just hate the charcters especially the main cast, i'm glad they stepped away from them for the latest 20 chap or so (118ch rn) and focused on what is actually good, some of the best charcters are side even minor charcters ,itami himself is pretty good being an actual adult with experince and not a self insert, tho it does seem like the author is trying to make him look pathetic sometimes, the 3 main girls are just plain annoying, rarely important sometimes wierd

if you like badassery, military schenanigans and is interested in the concept i totally recommend reading it, it's very dialouge packed so be ready (if you are not interested in the harem like normal person you should skip around a bit)

[also the manga is nowhere near finished there is barely a small chap every month so i'd recommend just putting it on the shelf for now]

9/10 story
7.3/10 art
6.5/10 characters
7.6/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful
DrStupid87's avatar
Jul 2, 2018

Gate is a rare gem amongst the thousands of mangas out there. It portrays a modern military (Japanese armed forces, the JSDF) versus an empire almost identical to the Romans.

Currently, after 75 chapters, I'm still looking forward to further releases. The story is interesting and well paced. You get to see both sides of an armed conflict and how the higher military powers operate and regulate the life of the troops on the ground. Whilst the modern day JSDF have very few issues taking on an entire bridgade of Roman style troopers, you don't mind the sheer overpowered nature of them. It's utterly cathartic, especially with a revenge hook at around chapter 35. There's a huge world and the MC (Special forces and an Otaku) gets to explore it all whilst trying to play peacemaker.

The art is very well detailed too. From the finer details on attack helicopters to the scales of Wyverns, it all looks believable. A hard feat for mangas to achieve. However, it can sometimes be hard to keep track of whats going on during fight scenes thanks to the intricacies.

The characters are all well thought out too. Even the side characters. They each have some personal charm and are unique to the imaginary world they inhabit. The only issue I have is with some fanservice parts as it detracts from the plot. That is still a minor headache compared to this fantastic story.

As a side note, it's very gratifying to see that Antagonists truly get what they deserve.

Everyone should read this!

10/10 story
8/10 art
8/10 characters
9/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful