Am I Your Daughter? - Reviews

Alt titles: Am I the Daughter?, Naega Ttarieyo?

Am I Your Daughter?
sort
YukinaZero's avatar
Nov 14, 2020

I can't stand the main character. First of all the author made her unable to close her gaping mouth for some reason and it really bothered me. Second  she's 18 years old but has an annoyingly young mentality even for someone that lived there entire life locked away without any normal human interactions.

I enjoyed every other characters point of view in this story BUT the main characters. She's just kind or a wierd too big toddler that acts funny. Thats the full extent of her entire personality and the people around her react to her like she's either the next coming or a hellspawn. In a nut shell, this manga has zero chill. Amusing at first, but annoying by chapter 34.

?/10 story
?/10 art
?/10 characters
6/10 overall
happydots's avatar
Nov 23, 2020

Usually, I'm a sucker for manhwas like this with the daddy-daughter trope, but there seems to be an oversaturation of manhwas like this with poor execution of the trope. The relationship between the main character and her father is so forced, like the author just wanted to have it there so she could hop on the hype train with all the other daddy-daughter manhwas. The male lead, the prince, is so bland – it's like he was just added in so the author could tick off the romance genre.

The manhwa's just bland. The characters are frustrating to read about. This is just another one of those manhwas where you think that this might be the one that's different from all the other ones, but it's just as bland. Exceeded my expectations with the first few chapters, but it all started going downhill.

I would not recommend. Don't waste your time.

6/10 story
7/10 art
6/10 characters
6/10 overall
IrisWhite143's avatar
Nov 13, 2020

This is the comic that the whole manhwa community has been obsessing over for the past few weeks. It started out really cute like all the parent-child stories, but right now it's still kind of boring where the dad doesn't accept her as his daughter, but he also kind of does... So much potential here, I'm still on the edge of my seat for the next chapter.

10/10 story
10/10 art
10/10 characters
8/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful
Djevel44's avatar
Nov 9, 2020

Got a good potential, i got to ch21 sadly what usualy ruins daddy daughter mangas like yyrse is the damn romance, for some reason it totaly ruins the story as it becomes to damn obvious what will happend.

Like every story its nice and wholesome to see the kid and dad grows closer and grow a Bond, but like with all stories like this the damn romance comes and fecks it all up, since not more is released than 21ch i can still pretty much tell what will happend, she will grow close to her dad and POOF put of nowhere she stops listening to her dad who want to keep her safe, she will have the Prince and a rival or more after her and it will be tons of drama.

I really do wonder if people actualy enjoy the romance in stories like this or most is like me who rather want to see the development with father or mother (depending on the story) and their growt together, honnestly i got no need to see that kid grow up to 18-20 years old and feck her relationship with her dad and get fought over by some possessive brats. 

8/10 story
9/10 art
8/10 characters
8/10 overall
1 2 this review is Funny Helpful
fishfood's avatar
May 9, 2021

I love reincarnation manga, but the story and characters are so one-dimensional and boring. A couple chapters in you already understand what the plot twists are going to be, which is usually fine if the characters are able to make up for what it lacks, but even they leave much to be desired themselves. The main character is incredibly unlikable and just incredibly boring even when she's acting cute. Usually I have some pity for the poor female leads too, but for this MC I could care less what happens to her. Even for the abused child trope it's difficult to feel any emotions for her, as her personality is very surface-level with no complex feelings,  thoughts or anything at all really in that peanut for a brain.  All we have is, cute abused child that likes cute things and is scared of everything as she experiences the world with default smile, default cry and default panic. 

Other characters are as memorable as a rock in the road that follow all of the stereotypical male leads in other manga with their roles switched around. 

Not worth your read or your time, but if you're looking for pretty art, go for it. 

2/10 story
6/10 art
2/10 characters
4/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful