The Promised Neverland

Discussion in 'Specific Manga Discussion' started by g3data, Nov 19, 2016.

  1. g3data

    g3data Well-Known Member

    Posted by g3data on Nov 19, 2016
    #1
    The Promised Neverland
    Alt title: Yakushoku no Neverland


    Synopsis, Reviews, Recommendations ~ Add Your Own Recommendations

    Discuss individual chapters and first impressions of this manga here. Full reviews should be posted here.
    ____________________________________________________

    I've read a handful of chapters of this.

    Surprisingly edgy considering that this is a Shonen Jump manga, which is odd since this is the same magazine that turned down Attack on Titan for that reason. Premise wise it's sort of like Animal Farm, but with humans being eaten and their caretaker not being an inept piece of shit like Jones.

    If you forget all that and just focus on the manga itself, the twist isn't much of a surprise. I've come to expect the worst from sequestered orphanages in anime/manga (Zankyou no Terror, Seraph of the End, Monster, Death Note, Kiznaiver, all of the top of my head).

    Not expecting to see many of these kids die though. Jump's gotta have a point where this kind of shit gets reigned in. Doesn't seem as schlocky as it could be. Can't tell if I'll like or not since the mind games between the kids and Mama have only begun as far as I've gotten.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Nov 21, 2016
  2. thor123

    thor123 Well-Known Member

    I'm actually up to date atm
    Not sure why you'd call this edgy? It is different from the average WSJ manga though.

    The mind games are fun so far imo, although too much of this will inevitably get stale. The thing I'm mostly worried about is what is going to happen AFTER they escape (I do expect them to succeed). I hope the authors have a plan on what to do next...
     
  3. g3data

    g3data Well-Known Member

    Posted by g3data on Nov 19, 2016
    #3
    I only meant by the magazine's standards. I've seen much worse obviously.
     
  4. Scruffy8642

    Scruffy8642 Active Member

    Yeh thats my issue as well. Hopefully they can pull something off that feels good. Although you would hope they had that all planned out well before they start the series, I mean it is the whole plot essentially.

    Yes this is Jump, but I dont see why this series has to be reigned in. Dont forget this magazine gave us Death Note and HxH which are both super gory and edgy. Death Note has deaths left, right and center, with some very gruesome.

    I have loved this series so far though. Love the facial expressions too. The series really does ride on what will happen after the escape though.
     
  5. thor123

    thor123 Well-Known Member

    Chapter 17
    well, the younger duo is making this more interesting at least. They've both shown that they're intelligent too (Gilda by getting the door open, Don by realizing Ray and the others might not be telling the entire truth) while their reckless actions make the group more... flexible? not sure if that's the right word here, but I'll go with that

    Also interesting: the year is at least 2043, while the latest book is from 2015.
    [​IMG]

    The morse code in the books is interesting too, especially since one of the codes spells promise - which is of course directly referencing the title.

    Now I'm curious to see how Don and Gilda will get out of the shit they've gotten themselves into
     
  6. Is anyone still reading this?
     
  7. thor123

    thor123 Well-Known Member

    Yep. Still going strong, and I liked most of the twists and tension here. Not sure why I forgot to post though :p
     
  8. I feel like the mangaka is strecthing the story thin in some aspects, particularly with the escape's planning but i will see how it goes
     
  9. g3data

    g3data Well-Known Member

    Posted by g3data on Apr 26, 2017
    #9
    Well the great escape is about finished so...
     
  10. thor123

    thor123 Well-Known Member

    well, I've mentioned it before, but I'm more concerned with what will happen after that ends. The way they'll build the outside world will be important, and I really hope they don't just time-skip right there :/
     
  11. Naga

    Naga Well-Known Member

    Posted by Naga on Dec 12, 2017
    #11
    I've read first chapter and it gives out Alice in the Wonderland (not the manga) vibes, but a lot more disturbing.

    It's interesting so I'll read more.
     
  12. Naga

    Naga Well-Known Member

    Posted by Naga on Dec 12, 2017
    #12
    So I've read til chapter twenty and I think this could be big if it gets adapted. I like the idea of the series and it's been really good so far.
     
    Yakoz and thor123 like this.
  13. sothis

    sothis Forum Moderator Anime-Planet Founder Developer

    Way too shounen at times but this is a very solid manga. First half is hardcore outside world/isolated society fodder with plenty of horror and disturbing reveals. Second half is adventure, mystery and danger that will remind you of Made in Abyss. I added recs for both Made in Abyss and Godspeed and encourage others to try these out / +1 the recs if you agree. Also added this to my in progress "unique world building manga" custom list
     
  14. DazaiCN

    DazaiCN New Member

    Just how many kids have escaped plantations, baby.
     
    TurkeyGami likes this.
  15. Ebonyslayer

    Ebonyslayer Well-Known Member

    Probably a lot since that figure head who calls himself Minerva has appeared.
     

Share This Page