Request to be added a featured custom list creator

Moderators are currently looking through the backlog of custom lists to find folks who have created custom lists that meet the featured guidelines. There’s a lot to look through, so if you’d like to request faster consideration, post about it here!

Before requesting, please ensure:

• You’ve read the featured guidelines

• For any would-be featured custom list, you’ve added reasons, updated titles and other content as needed to meet the guidelines.

• You’ve set any custom lists that don’t meet the guidelines to “people visiting my profile” or “no one”

Reply with confirmation of the above, and a link to your custom lists profile page, and we’ll take a look.

Thanks!

 

Is "manture" a typo? if not, what does it mean?

 

Hi everyone, I'm currently training the first person in a new team that can actively help with setting new featured lists, and looking out for others that aren't requested. Please bear with us as I'll be replying in batches (based on training sets of these). We'll get through all of them in here shortly!

 

Added - I can see that there might be missing tags in our entries for some of these. Some seem like slam dunks for the LGBT themes tag (if not all of them). If you're up for it would greatly appreciate your help suggesting tags (either adding or removing) in this section. Just make sure to give reasons for each tag as it makes the mods' approval easy :)

Additionally, if you know of other untranslated or obscure manga that we are missing in our database, let us know here.

 

Closing the loop on this, most people never replied, and it's been months, so I changed the featured lists to alphabetical ( @RogueLynx , @captivus , @Lorand123123 , @Hoshikochan , @Hrinn )

For @captivus please do remember to fill in the reasons for your "best" lists though

 

We've taken a look at this one, but it's hard to tell if it fits the guidelines

• The title seems unique - gorgeous characters (borderline too generic, but) + unique characters
• But the reasons don't say anything about why the characters are unique
• Also most of them seem more like "BL that I like" type of comments without much of a tie to the title

This one might be better to keep as personal tracking?

 

We've thought about this one carefully, but it doesn't seem to fit the guidelines quite right at this time. The title is fairly general ("Best story" can mean a lot of things and is broad), which sometimes is ok, but:

• Only some of the reasons are filled in

• Most of the reasons that are filled in seem more about why the anime is good in general, versus why the story, specifically, is better than usual in these anime. For example, HXH says "great action anime that has a good foundation" (unclear why this is one of the best stories/plots), some also just say what the plot is and not why it belongs on the list

Feels like this one might be better as a personal tracking list. thank you for the submission!

 

Everyone was pinged in the previous post similarly,

If you'd like to switch it back to ranked, make sure to put what the rank is in the description, as well as make sure the reasons make it clear why they're in that order. Your list isn't framed as a "Best of" right now, and the reasons are just the reasons why they're gentlemen, but there isn't much distinction between why some are at the top and some are at the bottom, etc.

tl;dr this looks a lot more like a collection list than a ranked list, so a few things would need to be updated first. I've switched it back to "profile" for now, let me know when it's updated :)

 

"List is sorted by who is the strongest example of a gentleman"

"List is sorted by hair color groupings" (this wouldnt work for your list specifically but it could work for, say, a tag-based list like "men who wear football helmets")

etc

Basically if the order is purposeful, it should be clear to the person looking at your list