It just so happened that on the both sides I was paired with people leaving exactly 1 message - signing up here. Happens. Two years in a row. @BubliFcuk You probably will never see this, but thank you for the recommendations nonetheless. Looking at your list, it looks like our tastes are different enough to the point where I might become a troublesome recipient. It doesn't look like you watched Anohana yourself, and that was the anime I enjoed the most out of all that were suggested to me, so I appreciate the thought. @Belph3gor You also probably won't see this, but I'm sorry for not being able to match your tastes and give suggestions interesting enough for you to give them a try. Though it doesn't look like you watched/read much at all lately, so maybe time was the bigger issue. I didn't really know what to pick, since I don't really read much manga, and your anime list is quite short. In case anyone wondering, here is what I picked: Manga: Ookami Shounen wa Kyou mo Uso wo Kasaneru, Heads Anime: Seirei no Moribito, Haibane Renmei P.S. I think I'm about to rewatch Haibane myself, the series totally deserves it.