Anime-Planet 2009 Anime Awards Winners

Discussion in 'Anime-Planet Annual Anime Awards' started by Cetonis, Apr 6, 2010.

  1. Cetonis

    Cetonis Forum Moderator

    Posted by Cetonis on Apr 6, 2010
    #1

    Anime-Planet 2009 Anime Awards Winners
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    -- Community Vote --



    Best Male Supporting Character
    [​IMG]

    Xerxes Break - Pandora Hearts

    Runners-up: Koizumi Itsuki - The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya 2009, Grell Sutcliffe - Kuroshitsuji
    Best Female Supporting Character
    [​IMG]

    Mari Kasukabe - Tokyo Magnitude 8.0

    Runners-up: Suruga Kanbaru - Bakemonogatari, Ami Kawashima - Toradora!
    Best OP Theme
    [​IMG]

    "Falling Down" - Eden of the East

    Runners-up: "Shut up and Explode" - Xam'd: Lost Memories
    Best ED Theme
    [​IMG]

    "Kimi no Shiranai Monogatari" - Bakemonogatari

    Runners-up: "Don't Say Lazy" - K-On!
    Best Late Arrival
    [​IMG]

    Himitsu: The Revelation

    Runners-up: Mouryou no Hako
    Best Comedy
    [​IMG]

    Skip Beat!

    Runners-up: K-On!, Maria Holic, Toradora!
    Best Action
    [​IMG]

    Soul Eater

    Runners-up: Darker Than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini, Canaan, Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom
    Best Mecha
    [​IMG]

    Gundam 00 S2

    Runners-up: None
    Best Drama
    [​IMG]

    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0

    Runners-up: Clannad After Story, Aoi Bungaku
    Best Scifi
    [​IMG]

    Eve no Jikan

    Runners-up: Summer Wars, Xam'd: Lost Memories
    Best Fantasy
    [​IMG]

    Spice and Wolf II

    Runners-up: Kemono no Souja Erin
    Best Romance
    [​IMG]

    Toradora!

    Runners-up: Clannad After Story, Hatsukoi Limited
    Best Mystery
    [​IMG]

    Eden of the East

    Runners-up: Kara no Kyoukai: The Garden of Sinners
    Best Slice-of-Life
    [​IMG]

    K-On!

    Runners-up: Ristorante Paradiso, Hatsukoi Limited
    Best Sports
    [​IMG]

    Hajime no Ippo: New Challenger

    Runners-up: One Outs
    Best Ecchi
    [​IMG]

    Kampfer

    Runners-up: Asu no Yoichi, Queen's Blade
    Best Horror
    [​IMG]

    Umineko no Naku Koro ni

    Runners-up: Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Rei, Aoi Bungaku
    Best Male Lead
    [​IMG]

    Akira Takizawa - Eden of the East

    Runners-up: Ryuuji Takasu - Toradora!, Hei - Darker Than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini
    Best Female Lead
    [​IMG]

    Holo - Spice and Wolf II

    Runners-up: Hitagi Senjougahara - Bakemonogatari, Kyoko Mogami - Skip Beat!, Taiga Aisaka - Toradora!
    Best Villain
    [​IMG]

    Liang Qi - Canaan

    Runners-up: Alphard - Canaan
    Best Full Cast
    [​IMG]

    Bakemonogatari

    Runners-up: Xam'd: Lost Memories
    Best Animation
    [​IMG]

    Bakemonogatari

    Runners-up: Canaan
    Best Music
    [​IMG]

    Kemono no Souja Erin

    Runners-up: Kara no Kyoukai
    Best Setting
    [​IMG]

    Spice and Wolf II

    Runners-up: Xam'd: Lost Memories
    Best Plot
    [​IMG]

    Eden of the East

    Runners-up: Tokyo Magnitude 8.0, Xam'd: Lost Memories
    Best Character Development
    [​IMG]

    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0

    Runners-up: Kemono no Souja Erin, Xam'd: Lost Memories
    Best Movie
    [​IMG]

    Summer Wars

    Runners-up: Kara no Kyoukai: The Garden of Sinners
    Best OVA
    [​IMG]

    Eve no Jikan

    Runners-up: Candy Boy, Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Rei

    Best Series Overall
    [​IMG]

    Eden of the East

    Runners-up: Tokyo Magnitude 8.0, Skip Beat!, Bakemonogatari

    Anime-Planet 2009 Anime Awards List

     
    Last edited by a moderator: Mar 1, 2016
  2. Cetonis

    Cetonis Forum Moderator

    Posted by Cetonis on Apr 6, 2010
    #2
    -- Panel Vote --



    Best Male Supporting Character
    (image is a spoiler)
    [​IMG]
    Grell Sutcliffe - Kuroshitsuji
    Best Female Supporting Character
    [​IMG]

    Mari Kasukabe - Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
    Best OP Theme
    [​IMG]

    "Falling Down" - Eden of the East
    Best ED Theme
    [​IMG]

    "Kimi no Shiranai Monogatari" - Bakemonogatari
    Best Late Arrival
    [​IMG]

    Himitsu: The Revelation
    Best Comedy
    [​IMG]

    Skip Beat!
    Best Action
    [​IMG]

    Soul Eater
    Best Mecha
    [​IMG]

    Gundam 00 S2
    Best Drama
    [​IMG]

    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
    Best Scifi
    [​IMG]

    Eve no Jikan
    Best Fantasy
    [​IMG]

    Kemono no Souja Erin
    Best Romance
    [​IMG]

    Toradora!
    Best Mystery
    [​IMG]

    Eden of the East
    Best Slice-of-Life
    [​IMG]

    Ristorante Paradiso
    Best Sports
    [​IMG]

    One Outs
    Best Ecchi
    [​IMG]

    Kampfer
    Best Horror
    [​IMG]

    Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Rei
    Best Male Lead
    [​IMG]

    Akira Takizawa - Eden of the East
    Best Female Lead
    [​IMG]

    Kyoko Mogami - Skip Beat!
    Best Villain
    [​IMG]

    Oda Nobunaga - Sengoku Basara
    Best Full Cast
    [​IMG]

    Bakemonogatari
    Best Animation
    [​IMG]

    Aoi Bungaku
    Best Music
    [​IMG]

    Kemono no Souja Erin
    Best Setting
    [​IMG]

    Michiko to Hatchin
    Best Plot
    [​IMG]

    Eden of the East
    Best Character Development
    [​IMG]

    Kemono no Souja Erin
    Best Movie
    [​IMG]

    Kara no Kyoukai: The Garden of Sinners
    Best OVA
    [​IMG]

    Eve no Jikan

    Best Series Overall
    [​IMG]

    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    --Bonus Votes--

    Worst Anime Overall: 11eyes
    Most Annoying Character: Natsuru Senou - Kampfer
    Improved with Age: Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
    Crashed and Burned: Soul Eater
    Biggest Disappointment: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya 2009
    Best Fight Scene: Bakemonogatari - ep08
    Koyomi Araragi vs Suruga Monkey
    Best Non-Fight Scene: Hayate no Gotoku!! - ep12
    Hinagiku sings Cruel Angel's Thesis
    Most Overrated: Clannad After Story
    Most Underrated: Kemono no Souja Erin
    Best Episode: Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 - ep11
    Best Animal: Chi - Chi's Sweet Home: Atarashii Ouchi
    Best Couple: Ryuuji & Taiga - Toradora!

    Choice votes!

    Funniest Scenes: Bakemonogatari eps 03-05 - Araragi vs Mayoi
    Anime that may have changed its genre: Eden of the East
    Anime that could make someone cry: Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
    Kamina Memorial Award for the most GAR character: Date Masamune – Sengoku Basara
    Biggest Pile of ‘What the freaking hell?!’: Kuchuu Buranko
    Yaoi-fangirl jailbait of the year: Ciel Phantomhive - Kuroshitsuji

     
    Last edited: Apr 7, 2010
  3. chii

    chii Well-Known Member

    Posted by chii on Apr 6, 2010
    #3
    well at least Kemono no Souja Erin won something...
     
  4. AirCommodore

    AirCommodore New Member

    Nothing too surprising. Hopefully the panel votes will end up with less repeat winners.
     
  5. Fireaxe

    Fireaxe Member

    Posted by Fireaxe on Apr 6, 2010
    #5
    Good work Cetonis!

    But.... Holo again... really?
    Kara no Kyoukai losing the Best Movie battle hurts me the most though. =(
     
  6. Omurqi

    Omurqi Member

    Posted by Omurqi on Apr 6, 2010
    #6
    As AirCommodore said, not much unexpected. I'm happily surprised that Kemono no Souja Erin made it as best music, seeing the show has a Watched count in the low 200s.

    Also a little surprised about Kara no Kyoukai not being first at "Best Movie". Though I can see Summer Wars appealing to almost everyone, where KnK's audience is a little smaller.
     
  7. Fireaxe

    Fireaxe Member

    Posted by Fireaxe on Apr 6, 2010
    #7
    And only the most hardcore fans out there have most likely seen the 3 movies that aired in 2009, which probably makes the audience even smaller.
     
  8. eaper

    eaper Active Member

    Posted by eaper on Apr 6, 2010
    #8
    I'd say no huge surprises, just a few smaller ones that were within expectations. Partially surprised K-On! didn't get anything else considering it has such a large fan base.
     
  9. Shinmaru

    Shinmaru New Member

    Also, Kara no Kyoukai had that god awful sixth movie. I love the fifth movie and like the seventh, but the sixth is just so terrible.

    Barely anything I voted in first won, but I'm not too grumpy about the awards. At least Basquash didn't win Best Mecha. I probably would have been found dangling from a rope if that were the case. Pleasantly surprised to see Kanbaru in the running for Best Supporting Female. She is my personal favorite of the Bakemonogatari girls.

    Speaking of, though, probably the only award I have a huge beef with is Bakemonogatari winning Best Animation, which is absurd. Great looking visually, but man, it has SO many animation shortcuts, like most everything SHAFT does (not that I'm knocking 'em too much; I enjoy SHAFT's style). How could any series with an episode like "Nadeko Snake, Part Two" possibly win Best Animation? Canaan may not be a better series than Bakemonogatari, but it has better animation by far (as does Darker than Black, which I voted for).
     
  10. Caraniel

    Caraniel New Member

    Some interesting winners there!

    Have to agree with Shinmaru about Bakemonogatari and Best Animation......its striking and quintessentially Shinbo/SHAFT, but clearly ran out of budget and took a ton of shortcuts.

    Aoi Bungaku was my top pick for animation, it was stunning.
     
  11. azanimefan

    azanimefan Active Member

    I think the issue was there was no topic for art. Art style Bakemonogatari was a feast. Easily the best looking anime of the year if you just took a random screenshot. I agree with you about "animation" however. (i think i voted for DtB and Caanan as well, to win over Bake)

    If there was a separate category for art i wouldn't have voted for bakemonogatari for animation.


    The only vote that bugs me is best female character. it bugs me for two reasons. 1) Horo won last year. 2) there were atleast 3 possibly as many as 5 female characters who was far stronger then Horo either year.

    It was a shame none of those characters won that category (though they did place as runners up), but it seems that just because Horo gets naked and none of the others do, it was an easy victory for the wolf. (don't get me wrong. I like Horo as a character. I think she's a great character. But she wasn't close to the best female character of this season)
     
  12. Cetonis

    Cetonis Forum Moderator

    Panel winners added ^_^ A little more than half of them were the same as the community winners, though I don't know if that's necessarily a "bad" thing. (or a "good" thing for that matter) Bonus votes are at the bottom there as well.

    Since it was edited out in the process, I'll restate that if anyone has a better 300x300 pic they'd rather I use for a particular anime, please pm it over to me. Also, somebody let me know if that panel supporting male pic is actually a spoiler or not -.-'

    As with last year, I'll post some of the actual point totals for the community vote in a little bit. Being that there were only 8-12 people for them, the panel votes were usually tight by nature, so I didn't bother posting panel runners-up or anything. Typically it was the same group of suspects as the community vote, with a sometimes-different winner of course. But the community tallies I will have counts for. There were a couple of ties, which is apt to bother some people on the side of the more-watched anime in each case, but that's how it was decided so it can't be helped. If someone has a better tiebreaker idea for next year, do say so.
     
  13. azanimefan

    azanimefan Active Member

    The panel vote results fixed most of the problems i had with the community vote. good panel!

    -btw: I found i agreed with the results from this year far more then the results from last year (in either vote)... other then Horo winning best fem in the community vote, not a single result really bugged me. I liked pretty much everything that won, or at least saw how they could win... well except for Soul Eater (which i found unbearable) and perhaps Eden of the East, which i felt was massively overrated (it was a good series... it was by no stretch of the imagination a great series)
     
  14. cassiesheepgirl

    cassiesheepgirl POPEE BELIEVER

    Not too many surprises, but at least my fear that Clanadd AS would wipe the board was wrong :)

    And Cetonis, yes the image for Grell is a spoiler. :)
     
  15. Kari5

    Kari5 Database Moderator

    Posted by Kari5 on Apr 6, 2010
    #15
    I was worried Ristorante Paradiso wouldn't get any awards :p At least it got one.
     
  16. madhattr999

    madhattr999 New Member

    Senjougahara should have won best female lead :P
     
  17. chii

    chii Well-Known Member

    Posted by chii on Apr 6, 2010
    #17
    **** YEAH!!! Panel votes make me WAY happy

    Best Fantasy Kemono no Souja Erin!! Best Slice-of-Life Ristorante Paradiso!!

    Awesome Female Lead and Villain! Same with Best Movie! Overall anime!!! SWEET

    The panel votes are way more awesome than the actual results with everyone else.

    only complaint from the panel was the ecchi was the same >.< stupid ****** kampfer
     
  18. Cetonis

    Cetonis Forum Moderator

    The promised point tallies - I'll list the top 5 or so for most categories, or wherever it starts to fall into a muddled pack of followers:
    --Series Overall--
    Eden of the East - 78
    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 - 58
    Skip Beat! - 46
    Bakemonogatari - 41
    Kemono no Souja Erin - 36
    Toradora! - 35
    Clannad After Story - 35
    (4 with 28-31 pts)

    --OVA--
    Eve no Jikan - 38
    Candy Boy - 17
    Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Rei - 17
    (3 with 8-9 pts)

    --Movie--
    Summer Wars - 31
    Kara no Kyoukai - 31
    (everything else waaay behind)


    --Plot--
    Eden of the East - 38
    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 - 17
    Xam'd: Lost Memories - 14
    (5 with 9-11 pts)

    --Setting--
    Spice & Wolf II - 27
    Xam'd: Lost Memories - 20
    (11 with 7-11 pts)

    --Character Development--
    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 - 30
    Kemono no Souja Erin - 20
    Xam'd: Lost Memories - 19
    Toradora! - 14
    Spice & Wolf II - 13
    (4 with 9-11 pts)

    --Late Arrival--
    Himitsu: The Revelation - 12
    Mouryou no Hako - 12
    (3 with 4-7 pts)

    --Animation--
    Bakemonogatari - 26
    Canaan - 21
    Eden of the East - 17
    Darker than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini - 15
    (5 with 11-13 pts)

    --Music--
    Kemono no Souja Erin - 21
    Kara no Kyoukai - 21
    K-On! - 16
    (3 with 12-13 pts)

    --OP Theme--
    Eden of the East - 39
    Xam'd: Lost Memories - 21
    Umineko no Naku Koro ni - 16
    Maria Holic - 14
    Darker than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini - 14
    (2 with 9 pts)

    --ED Theme--
    Bakmonogatari - 23
    K-On! - 20
    Darker than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini - 13
    Kuroshitsuji - 11
    Kara no Kyoukai - 9
    (6 with 5-7 pts)


    --Male Lead--
    Akira - 44
    Ryuuji - 19
    Hei - 17
    (6 with 10-12 pts)

    --Female Lead--
    Holo - 31
    Senjougahara - 28
    Kyoko - 25
    Taiga - 25
    Erin - 18
    (4 with 8-12 pts)

    --Male Supporting--
    Xerxes - 14
    Koizumi - 11
    Grell - 9
    (4 with 6-7 pts)

    --Female Supporting--
    Mari - 22
    Suruga - 10
    Ami - 9
    (8 with 5-6 pts)

    --Villain--
    Liang Qi - 15
    Alphard - 12
    Nobunaga - 11
    Medusa - 10
    Scythe Master - 9
    (6 with 6-8 pts)

    --Full Cast--
    Bakemonogatari - 17
    Xam'd: Lost Memories - 13
    (6 with 9-11 pts)


    --Comedy--
    Skip Beat! - 25
    K-On! - 24
    Toradora! - 20
    Maria Holic - 19
    (3 with 13-16 pts)

    --Action--
    Soul Eater - 32
    Darker Than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini - 27
    Canaan - 26
    Phantom - Requiem for the Phantom - 22
    (3 with 7-13 pts)

    --Scifi--
    Eve no Jikan - 33
    Summer Wars - 24
    Xam'd: Lost Memories - 24
    Casshern Sins - 16
    (4 with 5-8 pts)

    --Mecha--
    Gundam 00 S2 - 20
    (5 with 5-9 pts)

    --Fantasy--
    Spice & Wolf II - 33
    Kemono no Souja Erin - 27
    Sengoku Basara - 18
    Pandora Hearts - 17
    (5 with 5-9 pts)

    --Drama--
    Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 - 45
    Clannad After Story - 26
    Aoi Bungaku - 20
    (3 with 11-14 pts)

    --Romance--
    Toradora! - 55
    Clannad After Story - 31
    Hatsukoi Limited - 24
    (4 with 12-17 pts)

    --Mystery--
    Eden of the East - 45
    Kara no Kyoukai - 20
    Bakemonogatari - 16
    Umineko no Naku Koro ni - 14
    (rest with 3-9 pts)

    --Slice of Life--
    K-On! - 34
    Ristorante Paradiso - 19
    Hatsukoi Limited - 18
    Candy Boy - 15
    Kanamemo - 13
    (4 with 7-9 pts)

    --Sports--
    Hajime no Ippo: New Challenger - 20
    One Outs - 19
    Basquash! - 14
    (3 with 10-12 pts)

    --Horror--
    Umineko no Naku Koro ni - 20
    Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Rei - 20
    Aoi Bungaku - 15
    (rest with 3-5 pts)

    --Ecchi--
    Kampfer - 27
    Asu no Yoichi - 16
    Queen's Blade - 13
    (5 with 6-9 pts)
     
  19. SeiyaManG

    SeiyaManG Well-Known Member

    It was a pretty good vote. I'm glad Bake won some awards, even though Horo took the big award again. Nothing that particularly bothers me, just an observation: Xamd did really good in almost all categories for which it was eligible. Kinda sad it didn't win a single one, that feeling will probably be stronger once I actually watch the series, haha
     
  20. azanimefan

    azanimefan Active Member


    I doubt it.

    Don't get me wrong. Xam'ed was a good series... but i walked away from it with a sour taste in my mouth. It was one of those series that really could have benefited from better direction, as you can see some amazing material, and story... there was a lot to work with to make it truely epic. Unfortunately it always seemed to fall just short. the emotional scenes lacked punch. the plot was too disjointed and unfocused for most of the anime.. the ending was rushed, finally they wimped out at the very end (if they just stopped 2 minutes before the end it would have had a great ending which would have saved the anime from a lot of the problems)

    in the end, it was like watching a great batter get the pitch he's looking for and swing for the fences only to hit a pop fly back to the pitcher.
     

Share This Page