Phantom in the Twilight - Reviews

HKBattosai's avatar
Aug 29, 2018


As a character moderator trainee (at the time), I was left with a less than stellar list of remaining Summer 2018 season anime to choose from. Of the remaining selections, Phantom in the Twilight was what I chose be it good, bad, or indifferent.


College students, Bayrou Ton and Mu Shinyao, travel to London, England to study abroad. Little does Ton know that her fate is about to change forever, when on her first night there she stumbles into a small nightly café called Cafe Forbidden. She soon discovers a little about her past and learns about her great-grandmother's history as an Umbra Hunter and her relationship with the Twilights, the purpose of the café, and her newly found abilities that could be pivotal in the fight against the human organization know as the Midnight Sun.

The premise sounds interesting, but the series ends up being a let down with too many plot holes. There's just not enough continuity to clearly explain what is going on exactly.

Throughout the entire series the characters are still too much of a mystery, which then fails to drive the story. If fangirls are watching it for male eye-candy, then there are ample scenes that feature that. If your watching the show for any purpose other than that or just to give yourself something to-do, then you might find yourself sorely disappointed. One example would be the action scenes. Although usually well animated, they are very lack luster in substance. You never really get a sense of actual danger to the characters in most of the them, or they just end too abruptly and with the greatest of ease.


Very inconsisent in both art and in the actual animation itself. The backgrounds are generally good with some of the larger scenic ones looking very good (i.e. the overhead shots of London, England). However, the character quality is too inconsistent. There are too many times where they will look unrefined, then really sharp and detailed, and then unrefined again. This can happen from not just episode to episode, but from scene to scene as well. Both the mediocre art and the crisp looking art can get either really bad or can get enhanced nicely by the inconsistency in the animation; sometimes it's choppy, other times it's fluent. It's aggrevating because you don't know what to expect when coming to a particular scene. When Luke, Vlad, and the "other" Wayne are drawn and animated at their best, the visuals can be quite appealing.


Standard fair. The OP and ED music themes are okay. The music shows it's better moments during certain times of angst and during battles. The sound effects, such as Tauryu's minigun, building explosions, and Luke's werewolf slashes, among others, are solid as well. There's nothing spectacular but just enough to add to each scene appropriately.


The character development is on the weak side, except for Tauryu perhaps in episode four. We at least get a glimpse of his past, prior purpose, and significance to Rijan and now Ton. There are other snippets of character backgrounds astrewed throughout like in episode seven. It shows promise that more character development might be on the way, but then it never really materializes. On the positive side, the characters are relatively likeable and do have some individual personality that add at least a small amount of flair to themselves and the series.


Whether this anime should be written off as an "ignore it" series, a so-so series, or a worth-watching series is hard too say. The final episodes gave a decisive, conclusive ending while keeping it open for another possible season. Personally, I don't see a season two in the future but then again some really really bad anime have had multiple seasons, which Twilight in the Phantom is not the worst by far. In any case, if it does get a season two LIDEN FILMS is going to have to improve upon what they've started here.

This isn't a series that will blow you away with amazement, but at the very least it could be one that is entertaining enough to see it all the way through. If you end up watching the entire series because you are a fan of Reverse Harems, then even as a guy I can tell you that there are better anime out there, such as Ouran High School Host Club and Fruits Basket.


1️⃣Weighted Average System Score: (15 + 7 + 7 + 15 + 12 = 56/100 points)

Additional Information:

  • Video Format:  480p Streaming
  • Audio Format:  Japanese Audio (with English subtitles)
  • Publisher:  Crunchyroll
  • Equipment Used:  Lenovo TB-X103F Tablet (with Dolby Atmos)
5/10 story
7/10 animation
7/10 sound
5/10 characters
5.6/10 overall
kawaiikatt's avatar
Dec 7, 2019

I wish more reverse harems were like this, more on the side where the protagonist stands up for herself and can actually fight and not whine or wait for the guy to do something. I loved Ton's character also. Love how she wasn't too girly. On the flip side, the ending was pretty average and of course a cliffhanger that could have a second season but it won't. And I wished they were a bit more in depth with the background of each character.

8/10 story
10/10 animation
10/10 sound
8/10 characters
9/10 overall
KathyKatz's avatar
Sep 11, 2019

Wait...Wait a minute. The female protagonist actually does things and speaks for herself? I'm...watching a reverse harem right? (I am quite aware of the protagonist of Ouran High School Host Club)


So to begin with, Phantom in the Twilight tells the story about two college students by the name of Bayrou Ton and Mu Shinyao that have just arrived to London as they just enrolled in some college there, but things don't go as smoothly when a mysterious being ends up stealing their luggage. Leading our main protagonist, Bayrou Ton, in a wild goose chase in hopes of getting back her luggage, but instead stumbles upon a cafe by the name of Cafe Forbidden. This cafe is run by 4 Umbra dudes, umbras being creatures made out of human fear and anxiety such as vampires, werewolves, goblins and the like. So with the help of our 3 dudes, since one is introduced a bit later,  Vlad the blonde vampire, Tauryu, the human weapon, and Luke, the werewolf, Bayrou finally retrieves her luggage. Since this is anime, of course, the story doesn't end there as our protagonist ends up seeking the help of these 4 dudes once again when she realizes that her friend, Mu Shinyao, has been kidnapped. And that's where our adventure begins! 

So storywise, there were quite some unanswered questions left behind by this show. I am not sure if they just wanted to leave it to the viewer's interpretation or were they really plot holes, but they seemed more like plot holes in my opinion. Also, the one that must have bothered me the most was the reason behind Mu Shinyao just suddenly falling into Stockholm Syndrome with her kidnapper.


The animation was say the least. Sometimes the London landscapes would look really nice while other times the characters would look inconsistent. At times, you would get these detailed shots of the characters while in different frames the same quality wouldn't remain. Also, there was this CGI monsters that they battled at one point that really threw me off. Characters also had wonky expressions at times, but I think it's fairly decent. The visuals in the OP were also smooth and nice to look at.


I am no music expert, but personally I liked the OP song while the ED was fine. The background music did give out the intended atmosphere when it had to and the voice acting was solid as always especially Nobuhiko Okamoto playing Luke Bowen. He never fails to impress me.


I would like to give extra points for Bayrou not being a pushover, but I will just say things as they are. As much as I love this cast of characters, I believe they didn't really go through much development with the exception of Tauryu. There was also the inconclusive character arc of Wayne that kind of bothered me throught the show and it was unfortunately never resolved. Despite this, I believe the characters are fairly likeable not making you instantly hate them.

In conclusion, the show is okay. It has its flaws here and there but the show isn't terrible. I believe that for the quantity of reverse harems there are there, this one is much more bareable than others such as Diabolik Lovers. If you are into the reverse harem genre, then this one might be to your liking.

6.5/10 story
6/10 animation
7/10 sound
6/10 characters
6.3/10 overall
Mueslibitch's avatar
Sep 2, 2020

I love the protagonist and her way of doing things so much. 

?/10 story
?/10 animation
?/10 sound
?/10 characters
9/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful
YukinaZero's avatar
Sep 19, 2021

The Boys: 4/10, there not bad charcters but they just weren't appealing to me

The Ridicoulusness: 9/10, Bro that ending? Wild

The presentation: 7/10, overly dramatic, as it should be.

?/10 story
?/10 animation
?/10 sound
?/10 characters
7/10 overall
0 1 this review is Funny Helpful