One Piece Movie 6: Baron Omatsuri and the Secret Island - Reviews

Alt title: One Piece Movie 6: Omatsuri Danshaku to Himitsu no Shima

ThatAnimeSnob's avatar
May 12, 2012

This is the sixth One Piece movie, theoretically taking place after the Navarone arc and before they go to Water 7. Once again, it takes place around the same time as the previous two movies because the anime was by now slow as hell. An interesting thing about it, is how the formula so far was to make each movie being dedicated to a crew member (the first for Usopp, the second for Sanji, the third for Chopper, the fourth for Robin, and the fifth for Zorro). In this case, there wasn’t any focus given to anyone in particular. The hero ends up being the main rival (he is not really a villain) Baron Omatsuri. And if you stretch it, since everything he does is for the sake of his nakama, we could say he is the dark side of Luffy and in a way the movie is a tribute to him and the despair that can be caused by the loss of his friends.

Just like all movies, it is a filler mission with a good budget and a simplistic plot. But unlike the previous ones, this is by far the darkest, saddest, scariest, and most psychological of them all. It is also the most unorthodox of all the movies, as it was quite different from the overall feeling of the main series, to the point it felt like it wasn’t even taking place in the same universe. This unfortunately wasn’t received well by many fans who disliked the sad and gloomy atmosphere and expected just another goofy no-brainer. Quite a sad thing to say, since the previous movie was shallow as hell yet had more positive image for being just poser action instead of context. The majority of fans unfortunately expect fan service and not a dive into the psychological issues of its characters.

Down to it, I liked the sixth movie for doing the same as the fourth: Beginning in a simple and silly way and suddenly turning to something completely different, more dangerous and serious. The story is just about the Strawhat Pirates ending up in a pirate resort to have some fun. They take part in lots of silly games until suddenly they realize the owner of that place is hiding something. And before you know it, their darkest thoughts begin to surface and making them crazy or desperate. This is the awesomeness of the film; all the characters have a role by having their inner thoughts showing instead of being there just for the sake of fighting a mini-boss and goofing around.

All that is reflected by the owner, Baron Omatsuri, who is not just setting up a trap but also is part of the same issues they are going through. Thus in a way he “is” the main conflict and afflicts the heroes directly, instead of some generic villain with a weird power that has nothing to do with his personality. Thus he easily becomes the greatest rival of the whole non-canon cast (as well as most of the canon if you ask me). He is extremely powerful and doesn’t seek more power like all the previous bosses did but rather to maintain what he already has, to protect it with any means necessary.

One thing to be noted is how the movie does not have cool action scenes. In the first half they are goofy and random and in the second they are mostly of psychological nature. It wasn’t “exactly” about how strong Luffy is but rather how willing he is to keep going. Makes more sense in a way.

Another thing is the animation style which is quite artsy most of the time. During the peaceful moments it looks cheery and normal with rather minimal shading and fluent animation, but during the dangerous scenes it changes to this gritty, colourless, rough outline style, which is quite creepy and unorthodox. Many disliked it for not fitting the cheery style of everything else so far but I loved it for its artistic value alone.

A funny thing here is how Oda took ideas from the movie and added them to the canon story later on (a land of undead and a prison of despair). Yet the themes there were hardly as captivating or artsy, since they were stretched to last a hundred episodes and were watered down with lots of slapstick humour. Although for most of the target audience that is what they would prefer to having the show becoming scary and sad, someone like me who got fed up with the easy going plot is definitely going to appreciate the work they did here. I openly recommend to film NOT to the fans of the series but to those who seek experimentation and psychological conflict instead of poser action.

And now for some excused scorings.

Analysis: General Artwork 2/2, Character Figures 2/2, Backgrounds 2/2, Animation 2/2, Visual Effects 2/2

Analysis: Voice Acting 3/3, Music Themes 2/4, Sound Effects 3/3

Analysis: Premise 1/2, Pacing 2/2, Complexity 2/2, Plausibility 2/2, Conclusion 1/2

Analysis: Presence 2/2, Personality 2/2, Backdrop 2/2, Development 1/2, Catharsis 1/2

Analysis: Historical Value 0/3, Rewatchability 1/3, Memorability 3/4

Analysis: Art 1/1, Sound 1/2, Story 3/3, Characters 3/4

VERDICT: 7.5/10

8/10 story
10/10 animation
8/10 sound
8/10 characters
7.5/10 overall
eeveepkmnfan's avatar
May 5, 2012

This has to be my most favorite One Piece movie. I never would have thought that such a lighthearted and friendly anime/manga could be depicted as so creepy and chilling. Well, this movie proved it can be done.

From the start, this movie takes you on a journey. At first, Luffy and his crew get a flier advertising a wonderful island. Bored, Luffy decides to make everyone go. And from there, things only get more and more suspicious. The Strawhats can't find the place at first, and when they do, they're told they have to play and win three games. 

Once they get past that, things just get stranger and stranger. This movie takes you on a wild, mysterious thrill ride. From creepy strangers to shocking truths, and a majorly epic battle, One Piece has certainly outdone itself with this one. 

10/10 story
10/10 animation
10/10 sound
10/10 characters
10/10 overall
nasreen10's avatar
Sep 2, 2011

Story: It was a truly bizarre concept. I have never thought of One Piece as being creepy but this movie definitely was. However, we do get some action, comedy, and Luffy being a hero which is nice anytime of the day. It's not a complete waste but it is a pretty freaky movie. There are also some holes at the end though.

Animation: I have never given something a question mark but that is how strange the animation was. Usually animation for anime movies is similar to the anime itself but has better quality. This was completely different animation. I've a seen a very tiny amount of this style in the anime but it just felt strange watching because all of the cast just looked and moved differently which doesn't settle well. However, it does make it visually interesting so I am unsure with the scoring. Also, it does add to the creepy factor in this movie.

Sound: A little less than the anime. It didn't have my favorite soundtrack pieces which was disappointing. I don't remember much of it which says how lackluster it was.

Characters: Same as the series for the main cast. However, the villan and the other characters were lackluster or creepy. I didn't feel much for them.

Overall: It isn't awful but beware that this is kind of creepy and the animation style is different. I wouldn't purchase this movie but I don't regret watching it.

6/10 story
?/10 animation
6/10 sound
6/10 characters
6/10 overall
LunaNoah24's avatar
Apr 17, 2023

It looks likea horror anime, it feels like horror anime, but it is a ONE PIECE movie.

I genuinely LOVED it.

I was feeling so screaped out and uncomfortable that it was just AMAZING.

Was not expecting this type of story from the way it began.

10/10 story
10/10 animation
10/10 sound
10/10 characters
10/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful
PharuanUndearth's avatar
Jun 7, 2016

Ew, this is terrible. I get the psychological aspect of the movie but come on, at least make an effort in the animation. This garbage ass CGI of the forest, the giant CGI stem thing. Yuck.

Pros: Varied music, good characters, good character interactions.

Cons: Horrible CGI, worse overall drawings than the anime.

The music is steadily increasing in goodness, and I'm noticing it not being the standard OST. The characters and their interactions were very well done especially when the mentality of the characters starts to break down. I cannot forgive the animation being overall worse than the standard we get in the TV series, it's shocking really.

The story is the only saving grace even if the plot holes are as abundant as Briefs holes are all over the island. Dealing with the loss of those who are almost like family, a good example is how would you react if you lost your best friend, someone who you may have known more than half your life, that is some deep shit. But again where was this plant from, what happened when they meet Rodger, and what happened during the storm, is that a devil fruit power(but he looked shocked when he saw the powers)? Unanswered questions leave a big hole. 1-time watch only, and never again.

6/10 story
3/10 animation
5.5/10 sound
6/10 characters
5.1/10 overall
1 1 this review is Funny Helpful