One Piece Film: Red - Reviews

ThatAnimeSnob's avatar
Nov 9, 2022

For starters this is filler and no matter how much they try to make it seem like it’s canon, it’s not since the events are never mentioned in the series, nor they fit somewhere in specific. That aside, the movie sticks out from the precious ones, all of which were also filler, by having several pop idol songs, all of which are cringe. They don’t fit in the setting of One Piece and they are mostly animated with CGI so they don’t even look good. But even as a standalone story it doesn’t make any sense since there’s too much going on without proper build up. Most of it happens because the plot said so and not because it follows some sort of logic. This is where I begin spoiling the plot so if you don’t like that, stop right here.

If you are still here, this is why the movie sucks.
-The pop idol that Luffy was ‘supposed to know since they were kids but we never saw her in a flashback’, can trap everyone who listens to her music in an illusion. Inside that illusion she can shape reality as well turn people to toys if she likes. Something she doesn’t do to the Straw Hats and anyone else that helps them, because we wouldn’t have a plot if she did.
-There are a lot of extra characters in this movie and they don’t do anything besides using a special attack and calling it a day, they are just there for the fan service. Kalifa in specific did nothing, she was just talking on the phone throughout the movie. And the Thousand Sunny turns into a mascot animal for no reason. The only two extras that were useful were Law and Blueno and only because they could teleport Luffy wherever the plot wanted him to be, so even they were just plot devices so the story can move in whatever way the idiots who wrote this wanted.
-Then the pop idol uses snails that can project her music in the whole world, effectively introducing the internet and streaming in the One Piece setting, both of which will be forgotten when the movie ends.
-Then the navy is sent to stop the pop idol, and the marines never consider the option to Buster Call the island and be done with it even though it becomes a worldwide threat much bigger than even Ohara. Because we wouldn’t have a plot if they did.
-Then Shanks appears out of nowhere for plot armoring Luffy so the plot won’t end. Which is the same thing he does in the show as well, he just appears out of nowhere just to make sure the plot doesn’t end, and then leaves just as fast.
-Then the pop idol reveals her past which comes down to growing up on an island where everybody besides one man got killed. She never left that island and nobody came to repopulate it, because we wouldn’t have a plot if they did.
-Turns out everyone on the island had been killed by the pop idol when she summoned a demon lord with her music. What’s a demon lord doing in One Piece; it doesn’t fit one bit. It’s something she said she didn’t remember and Shanks never told her because he didn’t want her to feel bad. But he also never came back, never took her to a different island, and never told her to stop singing so the same thing won’t repeat, because we wouldn’t have a plot if he did.
-Turns out the pop idol knew what she did and kept singing, thus Shanks never coming back and not telling her the truth all these years was completely pointless. By the way, a girl that knows the truth but says nothing for years because she doesn’t want to hurt anyone, and ends up hurting countless people because of that. Does that remind you of something from the main series? Hello, Shirahoshi. They repeat one of the dumbest reveals in the entire show.
-Then the pop idol summons the demon lord, who is of course animated with CGI and looks awful, and everyone keeps punching him until he gets defeated. Because in shonen there is no problem that violence cannot fix. There is also a one second cameo of Gear 5, which doesn’t do anything, it’s just fan service in a filler movie.
-After the battle the navy is about to arrest everyone, but Shanks once again appears and makes sure the plot is not going to end, so everyone escapes. By the way, despite the movie being named after him, the focus of the plot is on the pop idol, not Shanks. Not even the title makes any sense. They named it after a character that not only is not the main focus, but is also the one who ruins the plot by existing just for plot armoring everyone. How incompetent can the people who made this be?
-The movie ends with the pop idol dying so we won’t get any more cringy songs with CGI animation. Thank god for that. And then there is a completely meaningless post credit scene where Luffy asks the ship if it can speak. And it doesn’t. What the shit was that? I waited 5 minutes after the credits rolled for nothing.

And that was the whole movie. What a shitfest. The only things I liked were the trippy animation when reality was merging with the illusion, and the pop idol not being forgiven for all the crap she did and then dying. That’s it. Terrible movie, Baron Omatsuri remains the best One Piece film.

1/10 story
8/10 animation
8/10 sound
1/10 characters
4/10 overall
d0ffy's avatar
Nov 14, 2022

Solid 9.5/10 movie, very unique compared to the others and a good satisfying ending.

I don't understand the low ratings at all, this movie was really good in my opinion. If you thought this movie was going to be all about Shanks you are seriously dumb. One Piece movies aren't fully canon so they can't go too far with the story. I understand that it wasn't what most people were expecting and that gear 5 was a waste, however in my opinion the music was really good and it was nice to see some older characters again. Plus if you are a One Piece fan you should just sit back and enjoy that they made a movie in the first place. 

8/10 story
9/10 animation
10/10 sound
9/10 characters
9.5/10 overall
OneEyeMonkey's avatar
Mar 20, 2023

I was bit unsure if people who went to see this movie with me in cinema would be even interested since they never even heard about one piece. Yet they enjoyed it a lot both action and music part and that i use a reason why this movie is good.

Story for sure is the weakest part in here yet its not bad nore boring but also not realy uniqu. Maybe cose i did 0 research on it i wasnt dissapointed as some other people i saw.(Shanks wasnt realy there). But it had everything what good one piece story needs good pasing, love, hate, anger, saddness and ofc fun.

Animation was bit suprising for me since i watched anime only till ep 400 or so. So seeing how better animation become was suprising and i liked it a lot.

Sound was for me and my friends what we enjoyied in this movie the most. Yes  I loved all the songs there and they were amazing and it made tipical one piece animation unique in its own way so this movie stands out thanks to it.

And for characters lets be honest here there are too many in the movie and there is no way all of them can get decent amount of screentime but onepiece characters are amazing.

7/10 story
9/10 animation
10/10 sound
9/10 characters
9/10 overall
Papii69's avatar
Nov 6, 2022

Its a musical 😴 Movie gets good once Shanks shows at the last 10 minutes of the movie . If you are expecting action you will be disapointed its 90% singing .  It was nice seing Red Hair Pirates in action after all these years even if it was just for 5 seconds 🙃 .

1/10 story
5/10 animation
1/10 sound
10/10 characters
1/10 overall
DonSlime's avatar
Apr 7, 2023

For all the hype it got, it really fell flat on it's face. This movie was super boring and felt both rushed and like it was dragging. If this was a pre time skip movie like right after that added Brook to the crew, I would've let it slide. They could've kept this crap in the vault somewhere

3/10 story
7.5/10 animation
?/10 sound
9/10 characters
3.5/10 overall