I tried to watch this, really. I'm honestly surprised I got as far in as I did. But oh god the lack of a plot, or any redeeming quality for that matter. Absolutely nothing made any sense to me and I could not even pretend to believe that this story was realistic in ANY WAY. This is the last time I listen to anonymous reccomendations, let me tell you. Like, I'm actually pretty mad about this. I'll explain my reasoning:
Story:
The story is impressively bad. The first episode has a very sudden love confession between the two main characters, which is a pet peeve of mine already. But the one in Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun has absolutely no context. Broken down, it would look something like this:
Bring school handouts to delinquent classmate who doesn't come to school
Receive a rape threat (!!?) from said delinquent and go yell at his "friends" for using him.
????
Romance!
And then they switch places. A lot, judging by the other reviews written for this anime. I didn't stick around to find out, but apparently nothing gets resolved romantically (even for the side characters, which is pretty sad). Oh, and the forced drama. Some.....thing happens with delinquent's family and he hates his brother and dad and he lives with his cousin to go to school but his dad wants him to quit school and come home and his brother comes to retreive him but his brother wants him to go to school and this apparently makes him evil and adukhdyftukseutierlatorwgjnjkfdhgdf. This is the part where I gave up. They tried to create tension and instead made everyone look really, really stupid.
But yeah, story sucks. NEXT!
Animation:
The animation is pretty decent, all things considered. It's probably my favorite aspect of the anime overall. The drawings are quite consistent. I think I only noticed a handful of derpy faces during the 5 episodes I saw. The actual drawing style itself is quite nice, not moe at all, a delight for those purists out there I'm sure (wink wink nudge nudge). Honestly, everything seems pretty standard to me, but then again I was kind of distracted by the glaring faults that are THE STORY AND THE CHARACTERS, A.K.A. THE MEAT ON THE BONES, SHALL WE SAY.
Sound:
Pretty much the same story with the sound as with the animation, pretty average. I'm notoriously bad for not really paying attention to the sound quality/soundtrack of anything ever. Like, it has to be good, Panty and Stocking with Garterbelt good, before I'd notice a thing. However, I did note that the voices did not seem to fit the stereotype of the characters they were protraying. Whch is good? I think? I mean to say that they did more for the characters than the writing did, they made them feel 1.5 dimensional rather than just 1 dimensional. No whiny "Oniiiiii-chan!"s to be heard!
Characters:
Wow, after writing all this I almost feel bad about being so negative. Almost. The characters of Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun basically took the weird storyline and made it difficult to explain to sane people (and on top of that you have to explain why you're watching it, too!). I don't even know where to start about the characters. Time for more handy bullet formatting!
The protagonist: a cold highschooler who has no emotions and is therefore automatically a horrible choice to cast as a main character, you would think, right? As expected, she is impossible to understand and relate to. The only thing more impossible than her personality is the concept that someone fell head over heels for her in one episode. How.
The delinquent: some guy pretending to have a troubled past and for some reason impulsively picks fights with everything ever. He friggin' hits girls, you guys. That alone makes him, yet again, a questionable choice for the romantic male lead. They tried to pass off his childishness as endearing, but it just came across as bratty and dumb.
The "normal" girl: I didn't really hate her, but that didn't save her from being super boring. Apparently she can't make friends because every guy is in love with her and girls are jealous. Or something like that.
Some other guy: yeah this guy has no purpose other than to fill up the weird hairstyle quota. And probably for side plot romance.
The rooster: yep, a rooster. I think his name's Nagoya, and that's the only name you get to know because he's the only character that matters. He's a cute rooster that lives on the school grounds in a coop built by the humans. 10/10 best character.
and also there's a student-council-glasses-girl-shy-type too, but that's not surprising at this point.
Overall:
I don't really have anything left to say at this point. Obviously, I severly dislike this anime, but I hope my super opinionated "review" doesn't sway you from watching this if you really want to. With that being said, feel free to commiserate with me in the comment section if this review moved you to tears, that finally, someone understands the emotional pain that is Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun. Now, I stayed up waaaay later than I intended to just to vomit angry words onto the internet, so I'm going to lay my sad soul to rest now.
(I've never written one of these, can't you tell?)