Lily C.A.T. - Reviews

sort
EverythingHuman's avatar
Mar 8, 2020

What would happen if the alien from "Alien" was the alien from "The Thing" and all of the characters were various anime tropes? Lily C.A.T. exhibits multiple direct references to both movies with some semi-original concepts tossed in. Lily C.A.T. turns out to be less then the sum of it's parts but it is recommended if you enjoyed Alien and The Thing.

PROS

  • Elements of both Alien and The Thing
  • Gruesome animation

CONS

  • Most of the "original" concepts
5.5/10 story
6.5/10 animation
6/10 sound
7/10 characters
7/10 overall
Bjoli's avatar
Feb 8, 2012

A claustrophobic space horror featuring character and monster designs from Amano Yoshitaka of Vampire Hunter D fame, Lily C.A.T. is not the best animated or produced film of all time, but it has a certain charm.  A lot of its appeal comes through its indebtedness to the Alien franchise, which it apes thoroughly with its design and storyline.  However, Lily C.A.T. lacks a strong central character like Ellen Ripley, and suffers badly for it.  None of the cast are particularly interesting, and just mimic overplayed tropes before shuffling off to die.

Thankfully, however, Amano had more sense than to provide a cheap Gieger rip-off to go along with the rest of the visuals, though there is something reminiscent of another '80s sci fi/horror classic, the Thing, in his designs.  Unfortunately, it's poorly explained and doesn't feel overly dangerous, meaning there's a lack of real tension in the climactic moments of the film.

Perhaps the best thing about Lily C.A.T. is the captain of the ship, who although he is not given enough time to really develop, provides an interesting window into cryogenic space travel in some of the quieter moments, and strikes avoids the militaristic cliches of many space captains.  Indeed, his character feels similar to later space-sailors Jet of Cowboy Bebop and Mal from Firefly.

The animation isn't stellar (no pun intended), but it doesn't descend into unwatchable territory, and stays fairly consistent.  The character designs aren't overly simple either, so that comes as something of a surprise.  As a final note, I should point out that I watched the English dub, which was surprisingly good, a few hokey lines not withstanding.

5/10 story
5/10 animation
6/10 sound
6/10 characters
5.5/10 overall
enki2's avatar
Jun 16, 2017

Lily C.A.T. is a mish-mash of ideas that will be familiar to western audiences: it's basically a combination of Alien and The Thing. It has a couple new ideas (like the alien monster being a colony of bacteria, and the Bishop character being a cat robot instead of an android), but these don't quite make up for the extent to which the rest of the film is a direct rip-off of these two better-known films -- down to setting design, plot points, and even individual animation cuts. One thing I will give it is that, for the time, the creature animations were great: it looks a lot better than the original Vampire Hunter D from around the same time, and the creature animation rivals some of the cuts from Akira's climax the following year. (The animation of the ships is not any better than Macross, and in some cases -- such as the ship's explosion -- is actually much worse.)

All in all, it's a fun (if unoriginal) flick and worth spending an hour and a half on if you're not sure whether or not you want to re-watch The Thing or Alien.

?/10 story
?/10 animation
?/10 sound
?/10 characters
3/10 overall
KarenAraragi's avatar
Jul 19, 2018

Cons

You want 80 bad shows then watch this. 

Over explanations. 

too many dead after giving info diarrhea on characters.  

Is like the anime wanting to be Aliens but forgot what made those movies good. 

I like harems show like love ru.  I like hentai. I like all sources of sickness but here the thing. There some scenes where they show boobs but without reason. They make naked statues of Donald Trump look appeling.  And I like DXD :/

Positives 

Time killer. 

Make you apreaciate less shitty anime

Make Michael Bay look like epic movie maker

Dub so that you don't waste time reading. 

Advice watch Pandorum

Or watch Spriggan not because is good but becaus is superbly animate and is heavy action pack.

Now if you want something that blast you away with super animetion but amazing plot and ending that will come from leftfield and you never see it comming.  Watch  Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade

I give the movie 5 stars because I enjoy the movie but doesn't mean is good. 

Edit I will give this anime 4 things.  The atmosphere is good really good and the animation is good but in the atencion to detail.   The anime use noise and music to effective to tell without  over explanation in certain scenes.  The anime has a briliant  moment where they talk about something almost not other anime or anything else for that matter address.  It actually make you pause and think about it. It make the captain views and reasoning make sense. 

1/10 story
10/10 animation
6/10 sound
1/10 characters
1/10 overall
0 0 this review is Funny Helpful