Intro
Before I begin this review, you, the reader, need to know upfront that there might be some noticeable bias on my part as it relates to Katana Maidens: Toji no Miko. The reason for that is simply because I have a personal interest and fascination in the construction, usage, art, etc. of both Japanese swords and swordsmanship.
Story: 12/30 points
When I first noticed this anime and saw its less than stellar rating of barely ⭐⭐⭐ (exactly 3.037 numerically out of 1,342 votes at the time of this published review), I just scoffed at the idea of watching this. However, what changed my mind was the fact that it is a Swordplay anime, so I thought to myself, “What the heck? Why not?” Let’s just say I was pleasantly surprised, although it might not seem like that as you read further down in my review.
Our actual story begins with the main characters of Kanami and Mai. They are two (of many) sword priestesses, known as Tojis, who wield specialized katanas made from a mysterious metal. These “Okanatas” have the incredible ability to defeat horribly CGI creatures known as Aradama, who reside in the Netherworld. However, they somehow find a way to make it humankind’s realm of Earth. How exactly? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
These Aradama are unique in many ways besides their horrendous look. They exist because of the metal that exists from the Okatanas’ construction. Yes, the same device that is used to slay them is how and why they exist in this world in the first place. Apparently, they are connected to it on physical, mental, and spiritual level that does not get described enough in the story. Because of that, if this is all confusing while reading this, then that is because I am still confused while writing it.
Heading back to Kanami and Mai, they have been selected to participate in an upcoming Toji tournament. These maidens, who are naturally Middle School Students, are the only ones to represent their one school (out of five), Minoseki Academy, in the assumed annual prestigious event. It is here where we are introduced to the other main character, Hiyori.
From the unexpected events of the tournament in episode two to the end of the anime, it is a story of saving the world through hard fought battles (sometimes), awful Aradama (typically), swordplay fan service (Woo-hoo!), and an up-and-down roller-coaster across two main story arcs that are incased in 24 episodes of oddly enjoyable anime. While its execution is clearly flawed, when done adequately, the concept can be interesting enough to draw the attention of the viewer.
Animation: 5/10 points
The Aradama look atrocious most of the time, except for Nene and princesses Ichikishimahime, Tagitsuhime, and Takirihime, which is primarily because they are mostly hand drawn if not completely done by hand. Speaking of hand drawn, the overall art style used is very basic, but cleanly done and consistent.
Another positive of the artwork (and actual animation) is the execution from hand drawn to CGI-based action when the Toji find themselves in a fight. Studio Gokumi does surprisingly good job in this, which is vital since there is so much swordplay throughout the entire series.
Sound: 7/10 points
The clanging of swords, the movements of the Tojis themselves, and most of the other sound effects are right on point. The music is admirable, but certainly nothing epic. The OP and the ED are decent, but forgettable.
Characters: 18/30 points
The characters are an interesting bunch with some development, but not enough to really make most of them stand out. All four of the main characters are middle school students, which most of the Tojis appear to be. The only Child among them is the Stoic Sayaka, who is excels with using an Okatana, until she faces off against Kanami, who is one of the standout characters. Kanami is the glue that binds their little Toji group together, which includes High School Students Eren and Kaoru. They all have physical characteristics and personalities that are typically found in many anime of similar genres, so I will not go into too much detail there.
What is unique about Katana Maidens: Toji no Miko is watching all the different fighting styles used by the various Toji, especially Kanami, Eren, and Yukari Origami. Kanami uses Yagyu Shinkage-Ryu, which utilizes an opponent’s movements and thoughts. Combined with her incredible willpower, intellect, and insight, she proves capable of eventually besting anyone in sword combat. Eren uses Taisha-Ryu, which is a high energy style that includes kenpo techniques and thrusting kicks. It is an unusual and unorthodox style that often confuses her opponents. The Dual Wielder Yukari uses Niten Ichi-Ryu, which utilizes techniques that elevate the usage of two swords. Her shear speed and strength further elevate her sword style to a nearly unbeatable level. There are many more Toji and fighting styles, but these are the ones that stood out the most when watching them in action.
Official clip from the Toji tournament
Lastly, I want to quickly mention Nene, who is Kaoru’s loyal companion and one heck of an Aradama.
Overall: 60/100 points
Even with mentioned flaws, I liked this anime more than I probably should have. Aside from the large amounts of swordplay action, there was enough here to make it an interesting watch.
Can I completely recommend it? No, but will say that is any of this review piqued your interest, then I would at least give it a chance by watching the first few episodes. That should be all it takes to know if Katana Maidens: Toji no Miko is for you or not.
Entertainment Score: 7/10 (2x)
Achievement Score: +4 to Overall
My expectations were Moderate, and it delivered Above those expectations.
Age Rating: TV-10+ (Violence, although not extreme; the scary, ugly Aradama)
Additional Information:
Video Format: FHD Streaming (1080p)
Audio Format: English dubbed
Publisher: FUNimation
Equipment Used: Acer AN515-53-55G9 Nitro 5 Laptop