Isekai Cheat Magician - Reviews

sort
scurvy135's avatar
Aug 30, 2019

This review will be spoiler-free for anyone who hasn't seen the anime, but wants to learn about it without getting spoiled. While I may not write this eloquently, I hope the review is helpful to whoever reads it.

This type of show is not easy to progress well, because it been done a lot. Unfortunately, while this show does start out strong, it shows cracks and begins to falter as the episodes progress. There are glaring plot holes in certain cases that show the lack of imagination and creativity of the writers. I like the premise of this show and I had high hopes for it, but in an effort to draw things out, they have skipped over some issues and even allowed laziness to take over in many shots. 

Animation: 

The animation is pretty good, for the most part. I have noticed certain shots where they have recycled previous scenes, which was diappointing, but not all that uncommon. What disappoints me further, is that some of the recylced scenes made no sense at that part of the episode. It's like they had a scene that worked better, but was drawn poorly, so they substituted a working previous scene to fill in the gap. That's terrible to do and shows a lack of work ethic from the animators. I'm sure there were more factors, but the result is not good and they shouldn't do it. 

Story: 

The story is fine, as it has been redone a lot. What makes this one unique is also fine, as I have made it to the 7th episode. But what bothers me, what prompted me to write this review, is how dumb certain things are. The lazy animation of huge spells, the lazy ideas of huge spells... It's like they thought this up in a few hours and rolled with it. The combination of elements to create the spells should be shown better, but isn't. I am REALLY disappointed with how the 6th episode turned out. When my own imagination can make an explosion look cooler than the animators did, I personally feel cheated. There was so much hype leading to certain scenes, but apparently they were either cut or were never meant to be shown. It's just really poorly done, in my opinion. That all being said, the 6th episode does not speak for the entire anime. The show leading up to the 6th, was mostly great. I will say that certain parts of this show make me squint my eyes and shake my head, asking "why" more often than I'd like. Terrible plot choices plague this show more than it should. 

Characters:

This is where most of my gripe comes in. Taichi is strangely written. He is supposed to have this amazing power, but he rarely gets to show it off. It mostly falls flat or he is held back in some silly way. The side characters, many of them are flimsy and don't have enough 'oomph' to them, for me to care. Rin is probably the most interesting, to me, because she has the most possibility. She can combine elements, with modern education, to create powerful new spells. Rin's character development has told us, the audience, that she is very intelligent and has a fantastic grasp over her suroundings. Rin is probably far smarter than the writers of the show are, because the writers don't do anything amazing with her until the 6th episode (where they totally botch it due to poor animation, in my opinion). There are other characters who feel one-dimensional as well, but I will let you see that for yourselves. 

EDIT: After watching the 7th episode, I am even more disappointed. The action sequences are like a kid playing with dolls, there is no pull or true interest. The intrigue and character usage is sloppy and sad. This show went from a 6/10 to a 4/10. 

EDIT again: I have dropped it. The anime has dropped every ball they had to hold. It's just a terrbile anime now. Very disappointing. 

Final Edit: Somehow, I made it through the whole season, even though I previously said I dropped it. My curiousity was too high, but I ended up clicking the scroll bar to skip ahead of boring/meaningless scenes. I hate this anime almost as much as I hate the dotHack series. It's a close one.

TL/DR; This show has some really great parts that make it a solid 6/10. But there are far too many problems with animtion, story decisions, and character development that cause it to fail completely. I would give it a 0 star rating for every episode after EP 6. EP 1-6 are pretty fun to watch, sorta. But because they screwed it up so bad, it creates a higher disappointment than if it were bad all the way through.  

3/10 story
5/10 animation
8/10 sound
1/10 characters
2/10 overall
foltor's avatar
Feb 28, 2020

In general, a new genre kicks off with a new work that defines that genre, and then subsequent additions add a new spin on that idea.

Knight's & Magic is isekai with mecha. Re/Zero is isekai where the protagonist keeps dying and starting over. Konosuba is isekai where the protagonist is just as much of a loser in the new world as he was bak home. That Time I Was Reincarnated as a Slime is isekai where the OP protagonist doesn't go about conquering the world. Rising of the Shield Hero is isekai where everyone hates the protagonist.

Isekai Cheat Magician doesn't have a spin. It is the isekai genre stripped to its very core. It is completely basic, generic, and unoriginal. It follows the formula exactly with no deviation, not even the romantic comedy of Wise Man's Grandchild or the harem dimension of The Master of Ragnarok. Which is, in a way, impressive. But it wasn't enjoyable.

There was exactly zero drama or suspense. Every move and development was completely predictable. Not only did we already know the destination, the journey had nothing to add.

In some cases, a bland story can be forgiven with good art and animation, or at least interesting worldbuilding. Isekai Cheat Magician has nothing to offer here, either. The most basic fantasy world, the most "C-" animation.

3/10 story
3/10 animation
?/10 sound
3/10 characters
3/10 overall
BaagaJB15's avatar
Sep 19, 2019

All I can say is don’t waste your time .

1/10 story
1/10 animation
1/10 sound
1/10 characters
1/10 overall
FalconX578's avatar
Jul 9, 2020

Based on the other reviews, you can probably already tell that this show is, to put it lightly, prettyy bad. However, to add on to the other twenty or so reviews, I'll also throw in my two cents—which was that this show sucked.

I had seen a bunch of ads for this show on Crunchyroll and thought, "Hey, why don't I give this a shot?" Don't give this a shot.

The show seems to capture the very raw essence of the whole "in another world" genre. But, it really didn't go any further than that. There was nothing interesting with this show that made it stand out to me. Two highschoolers get transported to some sort of JRPG fantasy world, and I guess it must have happened to these two before because they didn't seem the least bit concerned about it 15 minutes in, and their first instinct is to, "become adventurers!" with the absolute five-year-old's understanding they have about magic or literally anything else about the world they're in. As for the rest of the show, the story was super predictable and old and the least bit interesting. For a show about magic, there's nothing magical here.

Speaking of magic, even the magic was extremely underwhelming. Any fight scene looked subpar and cheap, but other than that, everything else looked fine. As for the sound, it was okay too. Nothing inoffensive with any of these two areas, but they only weigh down this show even further.

Now for the characters. Oh boy. Yeah they were pretty bad too. There was little to no character development for anyone to be completely honest. It seemed like it just jumped from point A to point C to point X without any transition. There was always some short timeskip or sudden event that no one cared for. The main female character did have some potential, since she managed to use her modern understanding of the science she learned in high school to help assist her in casting unique spell combinations, but this wasn't highlighted in any way, despite being the only unique and interesting thing to her. Because of this, she was left in the dust to be another hollow character.

When I started this show, I told my friends that it seemed extremely cheesy. Whether it was the way the characters reacted to everything, the whole story in general, it just felt off and weird. I expected that to go away, but it really didn't. I'd assume there will be a second season, though I will certainly not be one of the people to watch it. This show felt like it'd do great with kids or something, but if you're looking for meaningful story, vibrant characters, and an opening to add to your playlist of best anime openings, you'll be disappointed to find that this show has none of these.

TL;DR

|

This show is bland and boring, with cardboard cutout characters in a generic story. There's nothing memorable to be found, and the fight scenes are forgettable and underwhelming. I had heard someone say that this show's redeeming quality was in the two main characters that travelled to another world instead of one, however these two main characters don't stand out in any way. There are far better shows to watch with higher stars, and even though it's only 12 episodes, you could be using that time to do other better things other than watching Isekai Cheap Magician.

2/10 story
4/10 animation
5/10 sound
2/10 characters
2/10 overall
NightTonight's avatar
Sep 20, 2019

Generic trash that people watch, even though they know it the same anime with the same plot done with little to no budget to make it unique and stand out. :/ watch this if u trash like me :D

2/10 story
4/10 animation
4/10 sound
2/10 characters
1/10 overall