First three episodes aside, this season can be described in one word: Disappointing.
I highly suggest reading the manga of this arc (the first three episodes aren't in the manga but instead have a light novel as the source material; starting from episode 4 is where the manga picks it up), because it's much better. That would be chapters 38 - 52.
There are two major arcs (with a few "fillers" in between; I put that in quotes because though they seem to be fillers, they were still in the manga).
The first arc was probably the best this season had to offer, and spanned episodes 1-3. It revolved around mostly Chuuya as he searches for his relation to a creature of chaos/destruction which leads him to running into Dazai and the mafia, and is the story of how he joins the Port Mafia.
This was the best arc out of all of them, a solid 10/10.
The next episode is a prelude to the House of Rats arc (the major "arc" of the season), and then it goes into what seem to be filler of wrap-ups after the incident with the Guild. We see what Fitzgerald is up to, and there is an episode involving Kyouka and Demon Snow...as well as Atsushi and the Headmaster in that same episode. These "fillers" (again, they were in the manga, so not really fillers) between episode 4 and episode 8 (where the House of Rats arc really starts) are rushed and though were fun to watch, were severely lacking to their manga counterparts.
This section/arc earns a 3/10
The next set is the major arc of the season, the House of Rats arc which spans episodes 8-12. Fyodor, the "demon", is on the move to attempt to obtain the book for his own purposes. Since he doesn't have the resources like Fitzgerald did to try and destroy the city entirely, he uses his cunning mind which is on par with Dazai's own and pits the Port Mafia against the Armed Detective Agency.
Would have loved to give this a higher rating, but it was rushed and the final episode has many issues...so, sadly, I have to give the anime version of the House of Rats a 6/10 (and that's being generous). I'd give the manga a near perfect score.
Characters are the same as the ones from previous seasons, with the addition of new antagonists...so, I'm not going to give it its own section like I normally do
Sound and Animation
The opening and ending songs are brilliant, and again keep in tone with the feel of Bungou and the past two seasons of OPs and EDs. Not as fond of the arrangement in the visuals during the ending song, but it's not that bad. The OP and ED songs are what save the "sound" score...and the voice acting which was excellent as usual.
What kills the sound rating is the final episode, which has music in the background throughout nearly the entire episode, and much of the music doesn't match what's happening or the high-stakes incident on the screen. There were dozens of times when the music was too loud compared to the characters talking, and detracted from scenes which should have been much more impactful than they wound up being.
So, of course, major minus points for that. There were even a couple of times when the downward, thin-faced angle wasn't appropriate.
The animation all season has been weird. New angles are used (bug eyes and thin faces) to emphasize an eerie moment of a character just being creepy (or highly determined, in some cases). It certainly does accomplish the goal of emphasizing the emotion, but it's used so often that it just feels uncomfortable. Some of the character designs seem thinner than before, and the line thickness can't seem to stabilize. I believe prior seasons often had thicker lines for more comedic scenes, but this season couldn't seem to get that done properly and had a mis-match of line thickness.
The House of Rats was my favorite arc in the manga, and they blew it.
Things such as Kyoka's relation with Demon Snow and the chapter/half episode of Portrait of a Father were rushed to the point where the viewer can't even empathize with the character.
When I read Portrait of a Father for the first time in the manga, it actually hurt; I cried...and was horrified in all the right places. When the episode came out, it did things so wrong that I felt nothing.
If done properly, anime can make me cry even if I know what's coming due to the manga. BSD failed to contain any sort of emotional impact past episode 3.
Everything was so rushed...scenes were neglected, and even some explanations were neglected in favor of smushing it all together to cram 7 chapters with about 30 pages each (the House of Rats arc) into the span of episodes 8-12.
The ideas covered in this season (with the exception of episodes 1-3 which again, never made it to the manga from the light novel) spans chapters 38 - 52. All within episodes 4-12.
Oftentimes, there are scenes cut from the anime which were in a manga, but this time there were some more crucial things cut (one which was briefly touched upon in the final episode near the end). Then, of course, was the mess of a final episode.
Of all the complaints of "rush job" I have for this anime, the last episode is the worst offender in how rushed it was, barely being able to hear the characters talk over the music, and one scene where it would have had a much greater impact if they had at least silenced the music for the duration of the talking.
This season was just a mess. It started out strong, then started to go downhill at episode 4...and at episode 5, went even more downhill until episode 12 finally ended the sorry excuse of a season.
I urge people to read chapters 38 - 52 if you want the full experience of the House of Rats arc (after watching episodes 1-3 of this season).
As much as I like this series, everything after episode 3 left a bitter taste in my mouth which just kept getting worse. The job they did on the anime for this season makes it the worst season out of the three...even though in the manga, I felt it was one of the strongest.
If you're a fan of BSD, then definitely watch episodes 1-3. Past that, I'd suggest the manga over this awful attempt at animating the House of Rats arc. If you truly want to watch it, then there are some moments starting in episode 8 and up to 12 which are pretty cool...but it lacked the impact that the manga had, so I can't recommend the anime over the manga when it comes to the House of Rats arc.
This will be my general review about the series as a whole up until this current season.
It's been a while since a decent anime about detectives and mobsters has come about. Both tropes have been done to death certainly. Yet, Bungou Stray Dogs doesn't shy away from this. It knows it's cliched with all its dark and edgy tropes and rolls with it.
The amount of bad suicide jokes from Dasai and flashbacks of Atsushis abuse as a child could put Narutos emo edginess to shame. This has potential to turn many viewers off. Still, something about the show made me persist.
As I watched more, I learned these characters were more complex than first meets the eye. Their histories and lives heavily intertwined. I wanted to learn more about why Dasai was so hell bent on being a suicidal maniac, what exactly messed Atsushi up so much that he felt the need to prove himself so badly, and why was it that Akutagawa felt such violent distain towards the weretiger?
Oddly enough by the end of the third season and after watching the movie and ova's, I couldn't bring myself to dislike many of the characters. I even found myself liking the Port Mafia and wanting to see them fight with the ADA more to protect the city. Their interactions were entertaining for me and watching Dasai piss everyone off was hilarious.
I really grew to like Atsushi, as he changed and grew as a person, and I liked his contrast to Akutagawa, their relationship, and how they both relate to Dasai. This was probably what has kept me going through the series the most.
It's a series where you got to give it a couple episodes before you really get invested, and it might not be for every one, but at least give it a chance!
This review will be covering the entirety of the series, not just the third season! May contain spoilers.
For starters, the first season wasn't incredible, to say the least. However, it did serve its purpose. The first season generally introduced the main characters but didn't attain too much action, arguably. From the beginning, I did like the story. My one qualm with this series is the lack of screentime for the MC. Atsushi does not really get much from the series, despite being the infamous "Weretiger." This does not matter much to me, however, because each and every one of the side characters I adore. Honestly, I feel like they are written better than the MC and pertain to more important things. My favorite characters in this series were Dazai, Chunya, Akutagawa, Ranpo, Kyouka, Kunikidi, and Junichirou. The humor in that is that those are basically just all of the important characters that aren't the MC. I do like Atsushi, but I feel like his story and importance should have been implemented better. Other than that, the first season did a good job of getting the general feel of the show across to me/its audience, so I'd say that's not too bad.
The second season was good. It had much more action and got the MC to be more interesting to me. It also helped show the importance of some side characters, like Ranpo especially. This season certainly got me into this anime and is the reason I continued watching after not being super intrigued because of the first somewhat disappointing first twelve episodes. Introduced a plethora of exciting battles and abilities that I liked.
Walking Alone. I enjoyed this special episode very much. Getting to see more Kunikidi content was great and seeing his role more in-depth gave me good insight into this character. An interesting episode, good watch.
DEAD APPLE. This was a great movie! I loved getting some backstory/insight to previous Portmafia beef, as most of my favorite characters are/used to be a part of that squad. It was action-packed, which I love to see. The only issue with this was that if you weren't paying attention to everything that came before the start of this movie, you'd be totally lost. For some people, I'd assume that the beginning of this sort of just threw you into a plotline and that it was confusing if your full attention wasn't there. Since I watched all 3 seasons + this movie in one sitting, every previous event was still fresh in my mind. This made it very easy to follow, unlike some other people's experiences.
The third season! I loved this season. There was so much to enjoy here. For one, this season kept me on the edge of my seat. There was never a dull episode. Each battle was fulfilling to watch and greatly informational, they each were very entertaining. Characters like Fyodor, who had sinister motives, got my interest peaked. The ending was incredible! I am easy to please, so this review may not be all that important, but I greatly appreciated the last few episodes. For one, you get to see Akutagawa fighting with Atsushi!! I love watching them bicker, they are definitely displeased working as a team. But, they achieve so much. I wish I got to see them form a truce more often. Anyhow, this season had a very interesting series of events. I thoroughly enjoyed the Cannibalism parts. We got to see so much action. The only thing I disliked was not being able to see Chunya and Ranpo in a battle of wits! I'm sure I would've loved that.
In conclusion, I highly recommend this series to anybody keeping an eye on it. If you love complex characters and unique battle scenes, this is the one for you. I rate highly on most animes, so this review probably isn't the most informative, but I really do think most people who watch this anime will end up enjoying it.
This season started great, I just love how bungou stray dogs concentrate on its character's past and development. We get to see Dazai and Chuuya's past together, the first 3 episodes were great as the first 4 episodes of season 2. The more we know about Dazai's past the more we fell in love with his personality. I am excited to know more about his past.
After the flashback, the anime had some silly episodes which I thought they were filler, however, they were necessary to the development of the story.
Then last 4 episodes were great, we get to see the port mafia and the armed detective agency fight. That was great and adding these exciting ost, and then fight scenes made it more exciting to watch.
Overall the season had its up and downs, but I enjoyed like season 2.
I'm giving it a low rating solely because I don't like how they avoided Akutagawa's character development for the animation. Furthermore I don't like how they animated 15 instead of "Untold Origin of the Armed Detective Agency" for soukoku fans. Overall, really disappointing in that regard, but everything else was ok.