Bungo Stray Dogs 2nd Season - Reviews

*In anticipation of season 3, I'm sharing my thoughts. This review is for season 2, but Plot/Story and Characters sections touch on aspects relevant to season 1. Beware: minor spoilers ahead.*

Bungou Stray Dogs Season 2 is split into two parts: the first four episodes are flashbacks to Dazai's life as the youngest executive in the Port Mafia, told from his friend Oda's perspective; the latter eight episodes continue the main storyline, as the Armed Detective Agency takes on a new threat. 

The storyline and character arcs are deepened, the action kicks up a notch, and the score and animation are just as great as before. Overall, this is a step above season 1 but it's not without problems.

- PLOT/STORY 6/10 - 

The plot remains frustratingly imperfect this season, despite good pacing. Plot was also the weakest link of season 1 due to an apparent lack of an overall goal, which left me constantly wondering when the show would drop the comedic front and get down to business. Season 2, at least, didn't suffer from lack of an overall goal. Rather, that goal just wasn't all that interesting. 

The show seems to struggle to establish relevant stakes. Part of the problem is that it's done such a great job of convincing us that the characters are overpowered (I'm looking at you: Ranpo-san). There's a serious disconnect between the established storyline and the character arcs. Dazai's character - being already so far removed from the plot - saves this season with flying colors (more on him below). But season 3 could turn out to be really disappointing if this issue isn't resolved.

Overpowered characters aside, I have to say that Bungou Stray Dogs does a pretty good job of executing the overused superpower trope in a manner that feels refreshingly original. Yes, most characters are overpowered, but each has a specified weakness (except *cough* Ranpo-san *cough*) and Bungou Stray Dogs always makes it clear that the strongest characters are consistently the ones you least expect, often with the simplest abilities (a message I LOVE). It deepens character relationships significantly and kept me on my toes.

For example, one might immediately assume Akutagawa to be the strongest, given how versitile and offensive his ability is, or Kenji, who literally has super strength. However, its Dazai's strategic mind and ability to nullify a person's gift with a single touch that consistently enables him to gain the upper hand in almost every battle (despite the obvious fact that he completely lacks combat skills).

Dazai's former partner, Chuuya's, gift of manipulating gravity is also not an obvious candidate for strongest ability (just think of Ururaka from My Hero Acadamia). But Chuuya proves us wrong in one of the most epic fight scenes I've seen in awhile. Same goes for Oda's gift of seeing 5-6 seconds into the future - an ability initially disregarded by many, but one Dazai proclaimed to be too powerful for even Akutagawa to defeat.

This show is not about physical strength and the emphasis on morality and strategy makes the overpowered nature of some of these gifts forgivable. 

 - ANIMATION 10/10 - 

The animation is a cut above. I adore the style and art direction, particularly the character designs. No two characters look alike - their idiosyncracies are all represented on their person in some form and the colors/shapes of their eyes are striking (especially Atsushi's). They feel far more realistic than your average cast. Action sequences are also incredibly fluid. A real joy to watch. 

- SOUND 8.5/10 -

The score for Bungou Stray Dogs is mostly classical - something you don't see too often in anime of it's kind. Somehow, it all blends well with the J-pop opening, which is up there with some of my favorite anime openings ever. However, there were multiple instances when the sweeping melodies of the score felt out of sync with the storyline, which annoyed me (though this seems more like a storyline problem than a sound problem).

- CHARACTERS 10/10 - 

Here's where we see some major improvement from season 1. I don't think I've ever encountered such unique, interesting, and deeply realistic characters.

You've got our main character, Atsushi, who struggles to let go of the pity he feels towards how helpless he was in his past, but who makes every effort to be a genuinely good person. Then there's Kunikida, whose openness regarding his struggle to manifest his idealistic worldview (which also happens to be his ability, quite literally) makes him one of the kindest characters I've encountered, albeit rigidly pragmatic. 

And then of course there's Dazai, our favorite mysterious, mischevious, morally-gray shadow king. His role in season 1 seems to be purely comedic, but Dazai proves to be the center of gravity for literally every plot point in season 2. Learning about his past experiences in the Port Mafia and his deeply depressive struggle to find meaning in his lonely existence makes Bungou Stray Dogs one of the most mature shows I've seen to date.

But none of this is obvious - you have to do a little digging. Once you do, you'll realize our main character - Atsushi - and his rival - Akutagawa - actually represent the two sides of their mentor, Dazai. Atsushi represents the part of Dazai nurtured by Oda, which aspires to do good. Akutagawa, on the other hand, embodies Dazai's Dark Era, when he lacked any sense of righteousness and killed indiscriminately. Things get more interesting upon learning that while Dazai shows Atsushi patience and compassion, he repeatedly manipulates and abuses Akutagawa. 

Yes, Dazai is stupidly suicidal and the show somehow turns that into a genuinely comedic idiosyncracy. But by season 2, it's obvious Dazai could easily have killed himself by now if he really wanted to. To Dazai, living is unbearable and something he genuinely wants to escape. But it is the part of him that desperately desires to find a reason to live that leads him to foil his suicide attempts every single time. The tension between Atsushi and Akutagawa embodies, in part, Dazai's own struggle to reckon with his past motivations for living while still part of the Port Mafia. And it's a struggle that feels remarkably human.

Couple all that analysis with the fact that each character is named for a famous Japanese (or American) author and you have a whole additional layer of depth to consider (for starters, real-life Dazai died by double suicide), though I wish the original author took this symbolism a bit more seriously. The best part is that there is still so much room for character growth, development, and exploration, especially considering how little we still know about Dazai. Season 3 has a LOT it could deliver on and I couldn't be more stoked.

- CONCLUSION 8.63/10 -

Bungou Stray Dogs is one of the most polarizing and underrated anime out there, with mature themes and complex, realistic characters who stick with you over time. You'll either love it or hate it. If you would rather piece together character development than feel wowed by an epic storyline, then this is the anime for you. Otherwise, consider passing.

The second season of "Bungou Stray Dogs" continues the adventures of the Armed Detective Agency and the Port Mafia in a world where supernatural abilities are the norm. This season maintains some of the strengths of the series while introducing new elements to the story. However, it also has its share of potential drawbacks.

Strengths:

1. Character Growth: Season 2 delves deeper into the backstories and motivations of the characters, particularly characters like Dazai and Akutagawa. Their complexities are explored, adding depth to the overall narrative. Character development remains a strong point of the series.

2. Supernatural Battles: The action sequences in the second season are well-choreographed and dynamic. These battles between individuals with unique powers continue to be a highlight, offering exciting and strategic encounters.

3. Blend of Mystery and Action: "Bungou Stray Dogs" skillfully combines elements of mystery and action, presenting intriguing cases for the Armed Detective Agency to solve. The mysteries keep viewers engaged, while the action sequences provide thrilling moments.

4. World-Building: The series continues to build on its world, introducing new adversaries and expanding the supernatural lore. The cityscape serves as a rich and atmospheric backdrop, enhancing the setting.

Weaknesses:

1. Complex Narrative: The narrative can become convoluted at times, with multiple plot threads weaving together. While this complexity adds depth, it may require careful attention from viewers to fully grasp, potentially leading to confusion.

2. Occasional Pacing Issues: Similar to the first season, Season 2 exhibits occasional pacing issues. Moments of intense action can be followed by slower plot progression, which may disrupt the flow of the story.

In summary, "Bungou Stray Dogs" Season 2 offers a compelling continuation of the series, with character growth, imaginative battles, and a blend of mystery and action. However, it also presents challenges in terms of narrative complexity and occasional pacing issues. Despite these potential drawbacks, the second season delivers an engaging and emotionally charged continuation of the story, making it worth watching for fans of the series.

Almost immediatley, you'll notice that this season doesn't have as much comedy (though there's some here and there) and i'm glad for that. Now I can appreciate the action and drama more.

Hoenstly, I don't have much more to say. It carries on the greatness of what came before and that's what a sequel SHOULD do.

Nothing more to read here, move along! ;)

PS: Morgana from Persona 5 is in the OVA that comes with the Series 1 and 2 boxset, my life is complete.

( first episode review ) 

Obviously not commenting on the storyline nor characters  at this point . 

But the first episode starts of with past dazai from when he was in the port mafia .... good action and comedy from dazai side 

Animation and sound just like the first season  ( amazing ) 

- sorry that's all I have to say for now 😊 

Great addition to the first series. The comedy aspect was still present but you can clearly tell that the drama was more of the main focus! The fight scenes were amazing. Especially Akutagawa!!! His scenes were so cool.