My first impression of Psycho-pass was that someone was trying to recreate Death Note. It gew on me, however, and I've ultimately decided that it is a quietly good show which really tears into questions of morality and society.
-Really meaty themes: justice, controlling society, morality, good vs evil, etc.
-Never crosses over into cliches.
-Beautiful atmosphere, really fits the themes.
-Intriguing characters who wrestle with holding a complicated position in society/the story.
-Interesting end which was believable, resolved and yet didn't resolve. Good balance.
-Some one-dimensional characters/nothing really redeeming about the "evil" ones.
-Story gets off track here and there for no apparent purpose.
I'd say this a solidly above average show. Recommended for those who like a more mature/complex/nuanced take on the "good vs. evil" plot.