I consider my personal enjoyment of the show along with a look at the animation quality, directing, story, etc. when rating.
Anything below 2.5 I consider seriously bad (2.0) to appalling (.5).
2.5: The show is too typical, has glaring issues, or is just plain boring.
3.0: It's enjoyable and mostly worth the watch but feels lacking and/or it has something really holding it back.
3.5: A solid show that’s praiseworthy and entertaining but has memorable shortcoming(s).
4.0: Mostly top tier. Signifies a show that easily deserves recognition.
4.5: Top tier. Signifies a show that leaves an impression. Given to a great show that is admirable for its ideas and/or execution.
5.0: This is the score that is influenced by my opinion the most. Regardless the show still surpasses the criteria of a 4.5 and outshines all others shows like it.
*Please post comments freely*