roriconfan's avatar

roriconfan

  • Thessaloniki, Greece
  • Joined Dec 22, 2011
  • 33 / M

PROPER MINDSET
I really had no intention to watch another type of show such as this one but since most current anime are crap and a guy insisted, I just said OH WHAT THE HELL, MORE EXCUSES TO WRITE A REVIEW AND BASH THE ANIME INDUSTRY. So here I am watching this show called The Pet Girl of Sakurasou which is supposed to have some sort of good drama besides being fan service.

... One minute after the pilot episode begins I am already eye-rolling. We get the usual hentai-premise, a typical boring dork surrounded by hot girls who are all over him for NO FAKIN’ REASON and he is constantly not doing anything with them because it is not a hentai but a comedy. AHAHAHA-oh wait; that is not funny at all. Because all ecchi shows are exactly like that for the past 30 years and this one sure as hell doesn’t attempt to be original in the slightest.

PRODUCTION VALUES
Let’s start with what most of you will think right away. “Hey it’s a J.C. Staff show; time to fap to badly adapted softporn by some light novel.” Because that is the only thing they are ever doing and if any of you think they are anything more than that, I pity you. The production values are as always mediocre all across the board, from the done-to-death character achetypes, the cloned-into-infinity school grounds, to the jerky animation, the lazily-written songs, and the loose voice acting. There is no way to score the looks of this show with more than the base score.

SCRIPT
I wish I could describe the story to you but I can’t. No matter what I write you will easily confuse it with at least a dozen other shows which so happen to have THE EXACT SAME STORY. So I might as well make a checklist of all the stuff you get to find in here FOR THE MILLIONTH TIME.
- A completely average, typical, boring everyday high school male who loves to be obnoxious and to make an ass of himself on every chance he gets
- No sex despite all characters being hentai archetypes but nonetheless various excuses to masturbate while watching them not doing it
- A school that is somehow able to violate every rule and law in the world without being nuked from orbit
- A set of characters who you would normally only encounter in Arkham asylum
- Complete lack of common sense
- Pandering of all sorts for losers, NEETs, gamers, bored to death high schoolers

So anyways, the plot is about a guy in a problematic school full of horny pussies. He gets to stroke them but never to bang them. And I don’t mean the cats! One day the obligatory mysterious transfer student arrives and he needs to take care of her. And by take care of her I mean to do all things one would expect from deviant porn yet never really doing it with her because this is a comedy. AHAHA-not funny. No, really, that girl is completely autistic and you can do anything you want with her without giving a damn. But he doesn’t because for some reason being obnoxious and a loser overwrites your teenage urges. EVEN SHINJI MASTURBATES TO ASUKA!

Aha, but wait, now we are getting to the part where many say the show is very good at. You see that autistic girl is very talented in art and makes the completely average dork protagonist to look like dirt. Not that he already wasn’t with that obnoxious personality of his. So the plot is basically a genius having to rely on a commoner for all the trivial stuff; and by plot I mean the fan service and by trivial stuff all the erotic fetishes one can only dream of. Because this show couldn’t work if it was a serious take on the gap between the gifted and the everyday people; it had to be a J.C. Staff show.

Now in all honesty it depends on how you get to see the whole thing. If you perceive it as drama and romance with fan service and comedy then of course it is going to suck monkey balls since there is a ton of the later aspects. But if you lower your bar ssssssoooooo low to the point you somehow believe that any softporn goofball comedy is a masterpiece if it gently scratches a serious topic, then OMG THE ANIME OF THE MILLENNIA IS RIGHT HERE! THIS IS BETTER THAN SWORD ART ONLINE AND AS WE ALL KNOW SWORD ART ONLINE IS A MASTERPIECE!
… not.

For me? Well I can only place it a bit above a typical run of the mill ecchi comedy, which in turn is a bit above sea urchins and fruit flies.

CAST
Now I know many who loved the themes of the story. It is rather easy to identify with a guy who doesn’t excel at anything and be envious of a girl which was born to be better than you when it comes to important things. It is also cute to see how even the elite can be in need of the nobodies for the everyday things they take so granted to the point they can even perceive or handle. At the same time the show is not exactly doing much with the theme since it is as I said to the most part an ecchi comedy than romance or a social drama. Sorata is so obnoxious and scared of sex that I would hate him no matter how smart he was. And Shiina is basically an emotionless puppet that is ok to sleep with everyone just to get ideas for a shoujo manga; I couldn’t imagine her as nothing more than one of those huge anime pillows.

And then it’s the whole romance aspect of the show. If one can call it that. Beats me how exactly the main two characters fell in love with each other in two episodes if all I ever saw them doing is random ecchi stuff. And I never get it how all the chicks with issues always run to cry on the lap of the most boring and obnoxious male they can find, magically falling in love with him. There is literally a guy who has seduced every MILF there is right next to them; a jigolo of comfort and even does it for free. Why don’t they run to him for support; he obviously knows more about girls problems than the loser protagonist. Self insert character bullshit like this totally put me of.

LEGACY
Down to it the anime is not complete garbage but it is far from a great one. If there is one show J.C. Stuff did right, that would be Toradora. There weren’t such BS there, the romance felt more plausible, the fan service was very toned down. Pet Girl leaves comedy and turns to drama in the second half but it is sort of hard to like the change in the mood. Wouldn’t it be far better if it was a drama all along? And would it kill them to have sex instead of this done to death ecchi jokes? Those things are exactly what would make this anime to be great instead of just another comedy which tries a bit to be good. Not completely garbage as almost anything J.C. Stuff ever made, enjoyable for the casual romcom fans, but not exceptional.

And now for some excused scorings.

ART SECTION: 5/10
General Artwork 1/2 (generic)
Character Figures 1/2 (generic)
Backgrounds 1/2 (generic)
Animation 1/2 (basic)
Visual Effects 1/2 (basic)

SOUND SECTION: 6/10
Voice Acting 2/3 (corny but fitting with the feeling of the series)
Music Themes 2/4 (typical)
Sound Effects 2/3 (ok I guess)

STORY SECTION: 5/10
Premise 1/2 (typical)
Pacing 1/2 (erratic)
Complexity 1/2 (not much)
Plausibility 0/2 (none)
Conclusion 2/2 (simple but solid)

CHARACTER SECTION: 6/10
Presence 1/2 (generic)
Personality 2/2 (cheesy but well founded)
Backdrop 1/2 (generic and simplistic but it’s there)
Development 1/2 (overblown but it’s there)
Catharsis 1/2 (overblown but it’s there)

VALUE SECTION: 5/10
Historical Value 1/3 (OMG a JC show that doesn’t suck)
Rewatchability 2/3 (high if you like its silly style)
Memorability 2/4 (good when it is serious, bad when it isn’t)

ENJOYMENT SECTION: 3/10
Art 0/1 (looks typical)
Sound 0/2 (sounds meh)
Story 1/3 (feels generic to the most part)
Characters 2/4 (they are ok; could be great without the comedy and fan service)

VERDICT: 5/10

5/10 story
5/10 animation
6/10 sound
6/10 characters
5/10 overall

You must be logged in to leave comments. Login or sign up today!

Panta says...

P.S. I wasn't going to say this but fuck it: You went into this show expecting to see sex? And by your own admission I can assume you already had your hand wrapped around your dick from episode 1. If you're that desperate then go watch actual hentai; there's plenty out there.

For what this show is worth it's written well and has interesting characters that are slowly breaking out of the molds of their archetypes. Seeing development in characters as early as episode 4 and from people I trust praising it, I'm highly anticipating the rest of this show.

I'm just not seeing anything in the show that you're criticizing it for.

Feb 22, 2014
Panta says...

First off, I haven't watched as much as you have but I never got the impression you have about any of the cast. For starters, Sorata and Mashiro don't know that they love each other yet, and even if Sorata had a crush on Mashiro, you really think a socially awkward guy would be able to admit that to a girl he barely knows and is constantly having to babysit on a daily basis? I don't understand why you're expecting him to just shove his dick inside her and they'll both live happily ever after.

The reason people don't run to the sexual deviant for comfort is that sex doesn't solve problems, and the girls are aware enough to know that. They'd prefer someone who'll listen to someone who'll try to take advantage of their vulnerability - Jin even said himself that he couldn't be around Misaka when she's depressed because he'll use that against her. Being a womanizer doesn't instantly mean you intuitively "get" women and what they want to hear. And if you think you know human behaviour you're sorely wrong.

Maybe some people find sex comforting, but for the majority I've met being told what they want to hear is much better than being berated with cold truth, which Jin is renowned for doing.

Why does Mashiro do ecchi things to Sorata? Because she's socially different and doesn't see a body as something that has to be sexual all the time. It was painfully obvious that she was interested in Sorata's body for artistic purposes at first, and she has no bearing on being embarrassed about her own body. The best way to study situations and gain accuracy in literary work is to actually experience them, but since Mashiro has never been with a boy she needed to put herself in a similar situation where she could learn.

I can be comfortably nude around people too without seeing it as a sexual thing; Mashiro grew up in England, so she doesn't carry the same stigma as Japanese culture does towards it.

One last thing: Sorata is not the centre of any harem. Misaka has eyes only for Jin and Aoyama has a crush on him. Is it really unreasonable for more than one girl to have a crush on a guy? And so what if he's average and lacks ambition? He's a guy who's trustworthy and kind and someone you can confide in; that's what people want in a friend, and is what is attractive - for me at least - in a guy's personality. He is modest, and sure he's not got much going for him in the beginning but you're pulling a young kid down for being surrounded by talent when he has none himself. Wouldn't you feel a little depressed by that? I can understand why he felt like he did for the first few episodes, and he slowly gains his resolve to make something of himself, which is an admirable quality.

Most of what you've reviewed here is highly confused and makes me think you were asleep for parts and just decided to fill in what you missed with your own imagination.

Feb 22, 2014