I watch anime of all types and dont judge by genre. I've watched alot of anime, and im looking for new and interesting ones everyday.
My ratings for animes are as follows:
5 star = Watch this anime no matter what. Unique/entertaining all the way
4 1/2 star = Highly recommended, has something unique worth watching
4 star = Recommended for all, very good anime
3 1/2 star = Worth watching if you've heard of it, or already started watching
3 stars = Decent anime if you've got nothing to watch
2 1/2 stars or below = Dont bother with these, they arent worth your time
Dropped = The anime was either super boring or had nothing going for it.