Why register?

make an anime and manga list, and more! all free!

Theme

mangaislife

Fairy Tail

BASED ON 11 OF 43 VOLUMES STALLED
11 NOV
2010

In an unbelievably large step up from his previous work, the horrendous manga "Rave Master", Hiro Mashima throws off the shackles of unoriginality, cliche and inconsistency to focus on what he does best; characters. You can really tell that he was holding back in Rave Master, as each character had some kind of lame trademark that was being so desperately balanced by other parts of their personality that none of them were original or unique and they all came across as pretentious. However, in Fairy Tail, every single character has no balance. They are all extremes. And this works out fantastically. Each character is original and understandable, not to mention unique and likable.       The story is nonexistent and that's another reason this is far above Rave Master. Hiro Mashima's story writing abilities are subpar at best, so when he throws off the shackles of a continuing story and just puts a bunch of characters in a certain setting, it really works. Basically, it's a manga sandbox. Throw in a bunch of extreme characters, add a certain premise and do whatever the hell you want.       While I'm no fan of the majority of the battles in Rave Master, there were a few that really blew me away. However, in Fairy Tail, each battle is at a competent level and although nothing in the manga is fairly memorable, it's quite entertaining. Even when it starts adding plot and throwing in certain elements, you're really only just reading to watch the extreme characters interact. The story itself - when it starts to develop - is remiscent of some of the good parts in Rave Master, but still feels fairly pretentious.       The art is Hiro Mashima art. Better than Rave Master, but nothing magnificent. A fun read.  

Other Manga Reviews by mangaislife

ULTIMO user review by mangaislife

ULTIMO

overall score: 2.7/10

Rosario to Vampire user review by mangaislife

Rosario to Vampire

overall score: 2.6/10

Beast Master user review by mangaislife

Beast Master

overall score: 8/10

go to manga

User Review Scores

  • Story 5/10
  • Art 6/10
  • Characters 8/10
  • Overall 6.6/10

Recent Manga Reviews by mangaislife

comments

Lamme avatar Lamme
Feb 23, 2011

Yeah I was actually gettin really confused if this review was about Fairy Tail or Rave Master. Meh, well thanks for the review tho, I just ordered the first 3 volumes of this series and they will decide the fate of the manga for my part.

default avatar Eriu
Jan 9, 2011

Nice review, right to the point. Great characters, but the story sucks.

ZoomZoom avatar ZoomZoom
Nov 24, 2010

I think you should stop comparing it to Rave Master, and rate the actual manga itself.  It seems that you reviewed Rave Master instead of FT.

You must be logged in to leave review comments. Login or sign up today!