I'm Not interested in ecchi anime shoujo-ai or shonen-ai I'm not saying any thing against them but it's not one of my preferences
My rating system is the same as my friends
4.5 - 5.0 : This series is outstanding in it's genre and highly recommendable.
4.0 : This series is very good. It could use a few changes to make it better.
3.0 - 3.5 : This series is only mediocre. Okay for a decent read or to pass time.
0 - 2.5: Below average. Stay away from.
My favorite genre settings
1) Melodramatic with a bit of action funny at times with good plot (ex. code geass, death note)
2) Mysteries that just make you say WHAT?! at the end (ex. Higurashi)
3) totally funny or interesting plot with good/ likable characters(like ohshc hetalia or heart no kuni no alice)
I'm an artist you can see my art here http://darkharukan.deviantart.com/