When I'm not watching foreign horror films(with subs!!), watching good bad movies(think Troll2), painting, writing, working, or blogging, I can usually be found scouring for some new Anime. I'm not quite at the Otaku level, but I have started to catch on to some of the Japanese Language simply from watching show.
I'll pretty much try to give anything a chance. I like weird and osbscure the most, not that I'm not a big Naruto Shippuden fan as well. Also I love dark stuff that makes one utter the phrase WTF? I guess you know stuff like Higurashi or Evangelion. The important things I look for in both cinema and Anime- Good Story, Likable Characters(or even ones I hate but are very complex) and production value. The last more of the animation detail.
list of stuff I like at the moment
Mysterious Girlfreind X
Full Metal Alchemist
PetShop of Horror
Basically I'm rather eclectic in my anime viewing.