HOW I RATE ANIME:
5 - GEM STATUS. Perfection in everything. It also has to be re-watchable multiple times.
4.5 - ALMOST PERFECT. One small thing here or there that almost makes it a gem.
4 - VERY GOOD. More than one thing wrong with it, but still very good.
3 - AVERAGE. What 1/3 of anime falls into. Something leaves a bad taste in your mouth.
2 - MEDIOCRE. They got a few things right, but overall its not worth watching.
1 - FAILBOAT. They tried and failed...hard. Only the very elite can make it here.
This wonderful site keeps the blood flowing in my anime veins :D
For all those that keep asking, my avatar is General Jelly Jiggler from Bobobo :P
As far as dubs and subs go, I'm about a 50/50 split.
I enjoy long series, DVD Boxsets that are priced reasonably (under $1.50 per episode), and amazing music (Cowboy Bebop, Eureka 7....even the Lucky Star intro lol). I also enjoy good voice actors (aka NOT THE ENGLISH DUB OF GUNDAM 00).
Oh yea, and I am the King of Pineapple Soda. Just remember that :)
Currently still doing Naruto and One Piece anime and manga, since I love my long series. I'll be picking off some stuff on my Want to Watch list, starting with lots of Gundam.