You must be logged in to leave comments. Login or sign up today!
Hey, I never said there was anything 'wrong' with your ratings. It's just not the way I do things. (Or at least not yet? Ask me again in another 2 months of anime :P)
Give K-ON! 5 stars ASAP!
This is the same reason Rebuid gets such a high rating. It doesn't depend on any other medium.
One of the big reasons I don't have it higher tbh is that I try not to rate franchises. I didn't enjoy the series that much until I watched EoE. I would definitely not have enjoyed EoE without first having seen the series. Neither is a complete piece of art on its own imo, thus I can't really rate either as a complete masterpiece
Also I'm trying to avoid rating bloat at 4 stars like you have. It's at the upper end of my 3,5, if I watch more shows that are not so good I may end up bumping it up.
Oh and rebuild is at 4.5 stars, so... hey?