Ok lets start from the some less painfull things.
Very good - but it won't beat cell shading you can see in Clannad.
Fantastic - not much to say here.
Great. With exceptions...
Personally i like a story which is both amusing and can be easily found in real life.
This shows story is very amusing to a point where you realize Ryuuji ends will end up with Aisaka. If you'd cut out that part this show would be frikin great but like one person before:
"why is it so hard for those dumbass storywriters to actually get the right people together at the end of a story" - wargol
I fully agree with that...
Then again what should have i expected with Tsundere tag attached to the anime.
PS. Overall score would be probably 8 but personally i Hate the Tsundere thingy - it ruins good shows. That's why this was last Tsundere tagged anime ive watched...
PS.2 If you like Tsundere then knock yourself out =)
EDIT: Few anime's later - i guess i just got pissed off by this particular tsundere... (1->3)