I am one of the few males that enjoy romantic anime and manga. As long as it funny and the character grow in a relationship i will enjoy watching it. Ecchi is ok with me as long as there is plot or its just entertaining as hell. I normally avoid the pure fighting stuff expect for a few.
I watch and read many series so i know what is good and what is bad. I rate it on the content that it contains. I don't care if it is common story or the character look and act like someone from another anime or manga. It could be that person first anime/manga to them that is new. I try to be as unbias as possible.
My Anime rating system My Manga Rating System
5-Amazing(true work of art) 5- Beautiful Literature
4.5 (almost perfect) 4.5- Almost Perfect
4-Very good(few problems) 4- Some problems but still good
3.5 (better then average) 3.5 Above Average read
3-Average(a ok watch) 3- Average
2.5 (it is almost a decent watch) 2.5- Below Average
2-(Sucks) 2- Not worth time
1.5 (dont bother) 1.5 Need to skip
1-(Not Worth Your Life) 1- Why was this even written
ALSO the Manga are 10x better then the anime because most of the anime never finish the story but the manga do....