I keep track of everything I watch here so feel free to check my list out!
Just a little bit of information:
As a matter of policy, I don't watch shoujo-ai/shounen-ai. The main reason for this is because that's not my own orientation so it wouldn't appeal to me as much as what I am used to watching. I'm not the type of person who fits that viewing demographic.
I give 5 stars to shows that leave me speechless or put me in a great mood.
Even if I don't particularly love a show, I still try to watch as much of it as I can before labelling it as dropped or giving out a rating.