If I really enjoyed a title I'll give it three-and-a-half stars or higher. At least three-and-a-half means you would find it on my bookshelf. Except for five stars. I don't believe any title, past or present, will ever be worthy of a five star rating. Nothing's perfect. As for rating something I did not finish, I rate what I saw. Don't use my opinion on such a show as the law.