Overall Animation: 9.5
Charicter Design: 10
Character Detail: 9.5
Enviromental Detail: 9.5
Animation Quality Consistancy: 9.75
Overall Sound: 10
Complements Animation Style: 10.0
Matches/Enhances Mood: 10.0
Sound Quality: 10.0
Opening Song: 10.0
Ending Song: 10.0
Voice Acting: 10.0
Sound Effects: 10.0
Overall Characters: 8
Sadly the characters can be dumb as all hell at times which brings Overall Characters score down from a 10 to an eight. And yes, they really are that f**king stupid at a certain point in the anime. And the lead character is fairly stupid about several things during the whole show. However apart from this the overall character score would be an easy 10.
No comment on story except that it is exceptional but unless a second season is released you will need to go and read the manga if you want the complete story which sadly bumps the story's score from a 10 to an 8. But since it is still unclear whether there will be a second season I will leave it as a 10. But if two years from now there is still no season two the story's score should be concidered an 8.
If you are still unsure of whether you'd like this anime or not here is a list of anime. If you enjoyed at even just one anime on this list odds are very high you will love Deadman Wonderland.
This is an excellent anime that is both well written and wonderfully exicuted. However there are a few times in the anime that will leave you wondering if the characters are blind deaf and retarded. Which is the only flaw signifigant enough to bring the score from a 10 to a 9.5. Luckly this anime more than makes up for it's character's occational obliviousness with an amazing story, great animation, great music and wonderful voice acting.