Ok, I think I figured out a system I like. 5-stars = One of my favorites, or at least something I wouldn't scoff at being lumped in with my favorited. 4 stars = Liked it; thought it was good, but not one of my favorites. 3 stars = doesn't exist. 2 stars = Liked it to some degree, but at the same time though it was pretty bad / had some kind of glaring flaw that prevented it from being something I'd be able to call 'good'. 1 star = The last third of The Girl Who Leapt Through Time.