Here's a description of how I rate my anime:
5 stars - I wept at how amazingly good it was.
4.5 stars - Throughly enjoyed it, highly recommend.
4 stars - There was something wrong with it.
3.5 stars - Trash.
3 stars - Trash.
2.5 stars - Trash.
<2.5 stars - Trash.
Besides anime, who I am doesn't really matter here, so please imagine charitable things about me.
Some dude on the internet.