I've been into anime for a while but I only got heavily into it about 1 and a half years ago (current date Nov17 2009 - L4D2 fuck yeah) after watching Love Hina for the first time. My entire views on anime did a 180. Stopped watching stuff like Naruto and moved on to the Romance and Romance Comedy anime.
5 star - will definately watch again
4.5 star - was really awesome, probably watch again
4 star - very good, thouroughly enjoyed it
3 star - meh
2 star - well that sucked
1 star - fuck that.