I'm a casual anime fan. I try so hard to remember titles and names of characters, but I forget all the time (even with my favorite animes). I tend to like girly or romantic animes or kiddy ones (that's just my personality).
My Personal Ratings:
1/2 Stars: Hated it, maybe didn't even finish it it was so bad.
1 Stars: Really bad, I felt it was a waste of my time. Would not recommend to others.
2 Stars: Ok. Could have been a lot better.
3 Stars: Not horrible, but I won't watch it a second time.
4 Stars: I really enjoyed it. I'd watch it again and readily recommend it to others.
5 Stars: I loved it! I talk about it a lot and constantly tell others to watch it, too. I'll watch it again and again:)