"I am who I am, no more no less."
My first anime was Naruto around 5 years ago. My next animes were Death Note and Bleach. At the time I began to watch Death Note I had a mindset of "Naruto is so good why would I want to watch another?" So I didn't really look for more anime. That and I was watching episodes via youtube (lol). I don't really remember a specific order after that but my early animes were Black Cat, Blood+, Shakugan no Shana, and Elfen Lied.
Since then I've specifically developed the methods involved regarding finding, obtaining, and watching anime. I discover new shows through Netflix (no, really), ANN, word of mouth, and guides to animes about to air on tv. I 'obtain' a majority of the anime I've watched through direct downloads or torrents. Nyaatorrents is a decent site for all your Japanese otaku needs. As for how I WATCH anime...depending on the file type I'll put them on a flashdrive, and play through my PS3 (best circumstance, rarely happens). Otherwise I'll watch them on my second monitor (a 33" LCD tv), or my main (a 24" LED monitor) while playing PS3.
How I like my anime? Japanese audio, English subs - non-negotiable. I'd prefer fansubs, if only because they usually don't censor out the langauge...which in my humble opinion should stay there if it was intended.
Explanation of anime list: Watched = Anime I've seen all of, Watching = Anime I''m currently watching (ongoing will say watching), Want to watch = Anime I want to see, Stalled = Anime I'm on hiatus with, or Anime I currently have but have not started watching, Dropped = Anime I disliked so much that I stopped in the middle forever.